"I pity the French Cinema because it has no money. I pity the American Cinema because it has no ideas"
About this Quote
Godard’s jab lands because it flatters no one, not even the side he’s supposedly defending. “I pity” is the weapon: a posture of superiority disguised as compassion, the cool cruelty of a critic who’s already moved on to the next argument. He reduces two film empires to their perceived lacks - France to material scarcity, America to imaginative bankruptcy - and in doing so sketches his worldview: cinema dies either from starvation or from complacency.
The line carries the context of postwar European filmmaking, when French cinema faced chronic funding limits even as it cultivated an artisanal prestige culture. For Godard and the New Wave, poverty wasn’t just a constraint; it was leverage. Cheap equipment, location shooting, and nonprofessional energy became an aesthetic and a politics: the movie as an intervention rather than an industry product. So “no money” reads as lament and backhanded compliment: the French can’t compete at scale, but they might still take risks because they have to.
America, by contrast, isn’t accused of incompetence but of over-optimization. “No ideas” is Godard’s shorthand for a studio system that can purchase spectacle, but too often spends it insulating audiences from discomfort. It’s an argument about incentives: when money is abundant, risk becomes irrational, and originality gets outsourced to branding, genre formulas, and market research. Under the provocation sits a deeper claim: cinema isn’t threatened by censorship alone; it’s threatened by comfort.
The line carries the context of postwar European filmmaking, when French cinema faced chronic funding limits even as it cultivated an artisanal prestige culture. For Godard and the New Wave, poverty wasn’t just a constraint; it was leverage. Cheap equipment, location shooting, and nonprofessional energy became an aesthetic and a politics: the movie as an intervention rather than an industry product. So “no money” reads as lament and backhanded compliment: the French can’t compete at scale, but they might still take risks because they have to.
America, by contrast, isn’t accused of incompetence but of over-optimization. “No ideas” is Godard’s shorthand for a studio system that can purchase spectacle, but too often spends it insulating audiences from discomfort. It’s an argument about incentives: when money is abundant, risk becomes irrational, and originality gets outsourced to branding, genre formulas, and market research. Under the provocation sits a deeper claim: cinema isn’t threatened by censorship alone; it’s threatened by comfort.
Quote Details
| Topic | Movie |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Jean-Luc
Add to List
