"I read all the time. I was reading a book I admire very much by Alice McDermot called Charming Billy"
About this Quote
The modesty is the move. McGahern isn’t performing the writer as oracle; he’s performing the writer as reader, almost stubbornly ordinary: “I read all the time.” It lands like a statement of habit, not inspiration, which is precisely the point. For a novelist shaped by rural Ireland, censorship battles, and the long discipline of attention, reading isn’t a leisure activity. It’s the daily weather of the mind, the apprenticeship that never ends.
Then he narrows the lens to a single, contemporary admiration: Alice McDermott’s Charming Billy. That specificity matters. By naming a living peer (and an American one), McGahern quietly refuses the museum model of “literary influence” where writers genuflect only to the canon. He’s signaling a lineage of craft rather than prestige: McDermott’s controlled lyricism, her moral tenderness, her precision about family and small social worlds. In other words, he’s tipping his hand about what he values in fiction without giving a manifesto.
There’s subtext, too, in the unshowy verb “admire.” Not “love,” not “envy,” not “was dazzled by.” Admiration is disciplined; it implies close reading, attention to structure, an ethics of craft. For a writer often praised for restraint, this is a self-portrait in miniature: seriousness without self-mythology.
Contextually, it’s also a gentle corrective to the romantic fantasy of the solitary genius. McGahern puts himself in a community of sentences. The revelation isn’t the title he’s reading; it’s the posture: a major writer still behaving like a student, still listening.
Then he narrows the lens to a single, contemporary admiration: Alice McDermott’s Charming Billy. That specificity matters. By naming a living peer (and an American one), McGahern quietly refuses the museum model of “literary influence” where writers genuflect only to the canon. He’s signaling a lineage of craft rather than prestige: McDermott’s controlled lyricism, her moral tenderness, her precision about family and small social worlds. In other words, he’s tipping his hand about what he values in fiction without giving a manifesto.
There’s subtext, too, in the unshowy verb “admire.” Not “love,” not “envy,” not “was dazzled by.” Admiration is disciplined; it implies close reading, attention to structure, an ethics of craft. For a writer often praised for restraint, this is a self-portrait in miniature: seriousness without self-mythology.
Contextually, it’s also a gentle corrective to the romantic fantasy of the solitary genius. McGahern puts himself in a community of sentences. The revelation isn’t the title he’s reading; it’s the posture: a major writer still behaving like a student, still listening.
Quote Details
| Topic | Book |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by John
Add to List


