"I remember rehearsing it, and it was the one that we were really excited about and thought would sound the best, and once it was down on tape, it was like, This doesn't actually sound that good"
About this Quote
Studio mythmaking usually begins with certainty: you can feel the “best” take coming, you rehearse it into inevitability, you start pre-celebrating before the red light even goes on. Meg White’s line punctures that fantasy with a drummer’s blunt honesty. The excitement is real, even communal (“we”), but the tape doesn’t care. Recording is a lie detector: it captures not just performance but space, balance, mic placement, the way confidence can harden into stiffness. What felt electric in the room can collapse into something flat the moment it’s framed, measured, and made permanent.
The subtext is a quiet manifesto against rock’s usual bravado. White isn’t selling genius; she’s describing the ordinary cruelty of craft, where your strongest hunch can be disproven in three minutes of playback. That humility lands harder coming from The White Stripes’ world, where rawness and simplicity were treated as aesthetic truth. Her admission suggests that “raw” isn’t automatic; it’s curated through failure, through the willingness to toss the take you were sure would define the song.
There’s also something deeply human in the phrasing: “down on tape” turns inspiration into a physical object, and that object disappoints. Great records aren’t made by people who are always right. They’re made by people who can hear the mismatch between the fantasy and the sound, and keep going anyway.
The subtext is a quiet manifesto against rock’s usual bravado. White isn’t selling genius; she’s describing the ordinary cruelty of craft, where your strongest hunch can be disproven in three minutes of playback. That humility lands harder coming from The White Stripes’ world, where rawness and simplicity were treated as aesthetic truth. Her admission suggests that “raw” isn’t automatic; it’s curated through failure, through the willingness to toss the take you were sure would define the song.
There’s also something deeply human in the phrasing: “down on tape” turns inspiration into a physical object, and that object disappoints. Great records aren’t made by people who are always right. They’re made by people who can hear the mismatch between the fantasy and the sound, and keep going anyway.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Meg
Add to List

