"I simply cannot see how denying chemotherapy treatment for Palestinian children increases Israel's security or advances U.S. national interests"
About this Quote
The line is built to make a security argument feel morally untenable, not by preaching compassion in the abstract, but by forcing a concrete image into a policy debate: children, chemotherapy, denial. Lois Capps frames the issue as a logic test for hardliners. If the stated goal is safety, then explain how blocking cancer treatment fits. The question isn’t really a question; it’s a challenge to produce a coherent chain of cause and effect where none exists.
As a U.S. politician, she also triangulates her audience. The first clause targets Israeli decision-makers and their defenders: “Israel’s security” is the legitimizing language most restrictions hide behind. The second clause brings it home for Washington: “U.S. national interests” is the phrase that gives members of Congress permission to care without being accused of sentimentality or disloyalty. Capps is saying: even if you don’t give a damn about Palestinian suffering, this still fails your own metrics.
The subtext is sharper: policies marketed as counterterrorism are often blunt instruments that punish the vulnerable because it’s politically easy. “I simply cannot see” reads as studied restraint, the tone of someone inviting reasoned rebuttal while implying that any rebuttal would be grotesque. It’s a rhetorical move designed for hearings, op-eds, and cable-news clips: compress the humanitarian and the strategic into one sentence so opponents must defend the indefensible or concede the point.
As a U.S. politician, she also triangulates her audience. The first clause targets Israeli decision-makers and their defenders: “Israel’s security” is the legitimizing language most restrictions hide behind. The second clause brings it home for Washington: “U.S. national interests” is the phrase that gives members of Congress permission to care without being accused of sentimentality or disloyalty. Capps is saying: even if you don’t give a damn about Palestinian suffering, this still fails your own metrics.
The subtext is sharper: policies marketed as counterterrorism are often blunt instruments that punish the vulnerable because it’s politically easy. “I simply cannot see” reads as studied restraint, the tone of someone inviting reasoned rebuttal while implying that any rebuttal would be grotesque. It’s a rhetorical move designed for hearings, op-eds, and cable-news clips: compress the humanitarian and the strategic into one sentence so opponents must defend the indefensible or concede the point.
Quote Details
| Topic | Human Rights |
|---|
More Quotes by Lois
Add to List
