"I simply wanted to state that during this little slice of history, this is what happened and these were the good sides of it, these were the more dangerous sides of it, and this was the result"
About this Quote
There’s a director’s sleight of hand in Joffe’s phrasing: he sells you modesty ("I simply wanted") while quietly claiming the right to curate history. The line reads like a preemptive defense against the usual accusations lobbed at historical filmmaking - simplification, bias, spectacle. By calling it a "little slice of history", he narrows the frame on purpose, signaling that the work isn’t pretending to be definitive. It’s an argument with boundaries.
The real intent sits in the balancing act: "good sides" versus "more dangerous sides". That’s not just nuance; it’s a claim of fairness, a way to reassure the audience (and critics) that the film knows the seductions of its own material. Joffe’s subtext is that history doesn’t need to be sanitized into heroes and villains; it needs to be staged as a tension between progress and its costs. The inclusion of "result" is the tell: he’s less interested in archival completeness than in causal storytelling - how choices compound, how consequences harden.
Contextually, this fits Joffe’s career-long fascination with institutions under pressure (colonial power, religious authority, state violence) and with moral conflict framed through cinematic momentum. The quote also reflects a filmmaker’s belief that narrative can do a historian’s job differently: not by footnoting every variable, but by making trade-offs emotionally legible. He’s asking to be judged not on perfect accuracy, but on whether the movie captures the shape of a moment - its temptations, its risks, and what it leaves behind.
The real intent sits in the balancing act: "good sides" versus "more dangerous sides". That’s not just nuance; it’s a claim of fairness, a way to reassure the audience (and critics) that the film knows the seductions of its own material. Joffe’s subtext is that history doesn’t need to be sanitized into heroes and villains; it needs to be staged as a tension between progress and its costs. The inclusion of "result" is the tell: he’s less interested in archival completeness than in causal storytelling - how choices compound, how consequences harden.
Contextually, this fits Joffe’s career-long fascination with institutions under pressure (colonial power, religious authority, state violence) and with moral conflict framed through cinematic momentum. The quote also reflects a filmmaker’s belief that narrative can do a historian’s job differently: not by footnoting every variable, but by making trade-offs emotionally legible. He’s asking to be judged not on perfect accuracy, but on whether the movie captures the shape of a moment - its temptations, its risks, and what it leaves behind.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|
More Quotes by Roland
Add to List
