"I soon gave up instruction for self-teaching"
About this Quote
There’s a quiet defiance packed into Tommy Shaw’s matter-of-fact admission: “I soon gave up instruction for self-teaching.” It’s not a victory lap about genius; it’s a sideways critique of how formal training can flatten the very instincts that make a rock musician worth hearing. “Soon” matters. It suggests he tried the sanctioned path long enough to recognize its limits, then bailed before it could sand down his rough edges.
Coming from a working, touring musician, the line also reads like a survival strategy. Instruction implies a teacher, a curriculum, a hierarchy. Self-teaching implies urgency, obsession, and privacy: learning at the speed of curiosity, following the sounds that actually spark something, not the ones that earn a gold star. In rock culture especially, technique is always in tension with authenticity. Shaw’s phrasing chooses authenticity without insulting technique outright. He doesn’t say lessons are useless; he says they weren’t the engine.
The subtext is about authorship. Self-teaching isn’t just acquiring chops, it’s building a personal vocabulary before someone else’s rules become your inner critic. For a musician associated with arena-scale polish and tight songwriting, that’s the interesting twist: discipline can come from the bandstand as much as the classroom. The statement quietly reframes “education” as something earned through listening, failing, copying, and recombining, the way popular music actually evolves.
Coming from a working, touring musician, the line also reads like a survival strategy. Instruction implies a teacher, a curriculum, a hierarchy. Self-teaching implies urgency, obsession, and privacy: learning at the speed of curiosity, following the sounds that actually spark something, not the ones that earn a gold star. In rock culture especially, technique is always in tension with authenticity. Shaw’s phrasing chooses authenticity without insulting technique outright. He doesn’t say lessons are useless; he says they weren’t the engine.
The subtext is about authorship. Self-teaching isn’t just acquiring chops, it’s building a personal vocabulary before someone else’s rules become your inner critic. For a musician associated with arena-scale polish and tight songwriting, that’s the interesting twist: discipline can come from the bandstand as much as the classroom. The statement quietly reframes “education” as something earned through listening, failing, copying, and recombining, the way popular music actually evolves.
Quote Details
| Topic | Learning |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Tommy
Add to List





