"I suppose you all grant that woman is a human being. If she has a right to life she has a right to earn a support for that life. If a human being, she has a right to have her powers and faculties as a human being developed. If developed, she has a right to exercise them"
About this Quote
Her logic is deliberately spare and cumulative, built like steps you can’t easily skip. Human being -> right to life -> right to earn support for that life. It’s a neat reversal of the period’s sentimental defenses of women, which tended to frame them as dependents worth protecting. Rose insists on material reality: rights aren’t poems; they’re paychecks. By tying "life" to "support", she makes economic independence not a luxury or moral reward, but the practical condition of survival.
The subtext is sharper: if society blocks women from education and work, it isn’t merely unfair, it is denying their humanity in practice while pretending to affirm it in theory. "Powers and faculties" reads as both Enlightenment language and a quiet rebuke to the idea that womanly virtue is found in limitation. Development leads to exercise; exercise implies public participation, vocation, speech, leadership.
Context matters. Rose was a Polish-born, Jewish freethinker moving through American abolitionist and women’s rights circles where arguments had to persuade hostile legislatures and mixed audiences. This is activist rhetoric designed for the courtroom of public opinion: calm on the surface, radical in implication, turning the era’s own reverence for "rights" into a bill that patriarchy can’t pay.
Quote Details
| Topic | Human Rights |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
| Cite | Cite this Quote |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Rose, Ernestine L. (n.d.). I suppose you all grant that woman is a human being. If she has a right to life she has a right to earn a support for that life. If a human being, she has a right to have her powers and faculties as a human being developed. If developed, she has a right to exercise them. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/i-suppose-you-all-grant-that-woman-is-a-human-94276/
Chicago Style
Rose, Ernestine L. "I suppose you all grant that woman is a human being. If she has a right to life she has a right to earn a support for that life. If a human being, she has a right to have her powers and faculties as a human being developed. If developed, she has a right to exercise them." FixQuotes. Accessed February 2, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/i-suppose-you-all-grant-that-woman-is-a-human-94276/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"I suppose you all grant that woman is a human being. If she has a right to life she has a right to earn a support for that life. If a human being, she has a right to have her powers and faculties as a human being developed. If developed, she has a right to exercise them." FixQuotes, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/i-suppose-you-all-grant-that-woman-is-a-human-94276/. Accessed 2 Feb. 2026.












