"I think heterosexuality and homosexuality are a kind of psychosis, and the truth is somewhere in the middle"
About this Quote
Winterson’s line doesn’t read like a “both sides” shrug so much as a provocation aimed at the tidy confidence of labels. Calling heterosexuality and homosexuality “a kind of psychosis” is deliberately excessive: she’s borrowing the language of pathology to expose how sexuality has historically been treated as diagnosis, confession, and social sorting mechanism. The twist is that she turns that medicalizing gaze outward, toward the supposedly “normal” category too. If everyone is a little mad, no one gets to claim the calm authority of default.
The subtext is pure Winterson: identity as story, not specimen. Her fiction has long treated desire as fluid, imaginative, and unruly; this sentence compresses that worldview into a barb. “Psychosis” here functions less as a clinical claim than as a metaphor for the way cultures demand coherence from something that often isn’t coherent. We’re asked to notice how quickly desire becomes a badge, a tribe, a script for how to dress, vote, date, and talk about yourself. In that sense, the “madness” isn’t attraction; it’s the compulsion to make attraction explain everything.
“The truth is somewhere in the middle” is the trapdoor: it rejects the binary without pretending we can escape categories altogether. Winterson isn’t denying gay or straight lives; she’s questioning the idea that any single axis can hold the full range of intimacy, fantasy, and attachment. Contextually, coming out of late-20th-century Britain’s culture wars around queerness and respectability politics, the quote reads like a refusal to be made legible on demand: neither normal nor niche, just human - and messier than the labels allow.
The subtext is pure Winterson: identity as story, not specimen. Her fiction has long treated desire as fluid, imaginative, and unruly; this sentence compresses that worldview into a barb. “Psychosis” here functions less as a clinical claim than as a metaphor for the way cultures demand coherence from something that often isn’t coherent. We’re asked to notice how quickly desire becomes a badge, a tribe, a script for how to dress, vote, date, and talk about yourself. In that sense, the “madness” isn’t attraction; it’s the compulsion to make attraction explain everything.
“The truth is somewhere in the middle” is the trapdoor: it rejects the binary without pretending we can escape categories altogether. Winterson isn’t denying gay or straight lives; she’s questioning the idea that any single axis can hold the full range of intimacy, fantasy, and attachment. Contextually, coming out of late-20th-century Britain’s culture wars around queerness and respectability politics, the quote reads like a refusal to be made legible on demand: neither normal nor niche, just human - and messier than the labels allow.
Quote Details
| Topic | Equality |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Jeanette
Add to List






