"I think people have to choose between living with contradictions or painting themselves into a corner. I have a lot of contradictions"
About this Quote
There is a musician’s pragmatism baked into this line: life on tour, in scenes, in movements, means you meet yourself in different lighting. Michelle Shocked frames identity as a fork in the road. Either you tolerate your own inconsistencies, or you harden into a tidy, defensible persona and then spend years defending it. “Painting themselves into a corner” is the killer image: self-branding as entrapment, a DIY prison built one confident statement at a time.
The intent isn’t to confess hypocrisy so much as to pre-empt the courtroom mentality that fans and media love. In pop culture, contradictions are treated like evidence: gotcha screenshots, old lyrics, old interviews, old causes. Shocked flips that logic. Contradiction becomes a sign of motion rather than fraud, a refusal to turn a living person into a finished product.
The subtext is also about artistic survival. Musicians are expected to be consistent in the one way that sells: coherent politics, coherent vibe, coherent “authenticity.” But songwriting often comes from conflict, not coherence. To admit “I have a lot of contradictions” is to stake a claim for complexity in an industry that rewards clean narratives.
Contextually, Shocked’s career sits in the friction between folk’s moral seriousness and rock’s contrarian individualism. That collision makes the line read like both defense and mission statement: if you want the music to stay alive, you have to let the person stay unfinished.
The intent isn’t to confess hypocrisy so much as to pre-empt the courtroom mentality that fans and media love. In pop culture, contradictions are treated like evidence: gotcha screenshots, old lyrics, old interviews, old causes. Shocked flips that logic. Contradiction becomes a sign of motion rather than fraud, a refusal to turn a living person into a finished product.
The subtext is also about artistic survival. Musicians are expected to be consistent in the one way that sells: coherent politics, coherent vibe, coherent “authenticity.” But songwriting often comes from conflict, not coherence. To admit “I have a lot of contradictions” is to stake a claim for complexity in an industry that rewards clean narratives.
Contextually, Shocked’s career sits in the friction between folk’s moral seriousness and rock’s contrarian individualism. That collision makes the line read like both defense and mission statement: if you want the music to stay alive, you have to let the person stay unfinished.
Quote Details
| Topic | Deep |
|---|
More Quotes by Michelle
Add to List
