"I think some of the things I deal with Hopper probably has dealt with also, since it's somewhat the same environment and I have pretty strong reactions to what this country looks like. It looks pretty dull and spare, and you like this and dislike it and it's very complicated"
About this Quote
Judd is confessing that Minimalism was never meant to be a cold style exercise; it was a nervous system response to America. By invoking Edward Hopper, he links two artists often filed under “quiet” and “austere” and insists their spareness is not a pose but an environmental diagnosis. Hopper’s lonely diners and empty streets aren’t just compositions; they’re mood reports from a built world that can feel stripped of warmth. Judd hears the same hum in his own time: the boxy repetitions, the industrial materials, the refusal of flourish read like an echo of the country’s flattened horizons and standardized spaces.
The line “pretty dull and spare” is doing double duty. It’s critique and attraction, a blunt acknowledgment that the American landscape can be aesthetically punishing and strangely clean, deadening and clarifying at once. Judd’s candor also undercuts the macho myth of the Minimalist as a pure formalist, above politics, above feeling. He admits “strong reactions,” then admits the contradiction: “you like this and dislike it.” That push-pull is the engine. His work courts the discipline of the factory and the grid while flinching at what those systems do to experience.
Context matters: postwar America’s boom turns space into product, architecture into repeatable unit, art into commodity. Judd’s insistence that it’s “very complicated” reads like a refusal of easy moralizing. He’s not preaching against America so much as registering its texture: the seduction of order, the grief of emptiness, the way the same environment can offer both freedom and suffocation.
The line “pretty dull and spare” is doing double duty. It’s critique and attraction, a blunt acknowledgment that the American landscape can be aesthetically punishing and strangely clean, deadening and clarifying at once. Judd’s candor also undercuts the macho myth of the Minimalist as a pure formalist, above politics, above feeling. He admits “strong reactions,” then admits the contradiction: “you like this and dislike it.” That push-pull is the engine. His work courts the discipline of the factory and the grid while flinching at what those systems do to experience.
Context matters: postwar America’s boom turns space into product, architecture into repeatable unit, art into commodity. Judd’s insistence that it’s “very complicated” reads like a refusal of easy moralizing. He’s not preaching against America so much as registering its texture: the seduction of order, the grief of emptiness, the way the same environment can offer both freedom and suffocation.
Quote Details
| Topic | Art |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Donald
Add to List





