"I think that there are empty ecological niches in the literary landscape crying to be filled and when a book more or less fills a niche it's seized on, even when it's a far from perfect fit"
About this Quote
Literature, Edmund White suggests, doesn’t just evolve through genius; it evolves through vacancies. His “empty ecological niches” metaphor drags the book world out of the romantic realm of solitary inspiration and into something closer to natural selection: an ecosystem where trends, institutions, anxieties, and appetites create pockets of demand. When readers and critics feel a gap - a missing kind of story, a neglected community, an unarticulated mood - they start scanning for anything that can plausibly occupy it.
The sharpness is in the quiet demystification. White isn’t insulting writers so much as puncturing the fantasy that reception is purely meritocratic. “Seized on” is a blunt verb: the public doesn’t gently discover; it grabs, claims, rallies. That’s how books become “important” faster than they become good. The niche itself confers value, because it answers a cultural need, not necessarily because the craft is flawless.
Subtext: the marketplace and the discourse machine (publishers, reviewers, prize committees, book clubs) are constantly hungry for “the” novel that represents a moment or a constituency. White, long central to gay American letters, knows how quickly a single work can be anointed as representative simply because the field is underpopulated or newly visible. The burden on the book becomes unfairly symbolic.
His final clause - “even when it’s a far from perfect fit” - carries both skepticism and rue. Cultural ecosystems don’t wait for ideal specimens. They promote the first credible organism that wanders into the clearing, then retroactively treat it like destiny.
The sharpness is in the quiet demystification. White isn’t insulting writers so much as puncturing the fantasy that reception is purely meritocratic. “Seized on” is a blunt verb: the public doesn’t gently discover; it grabs, claims, rallies. That’s how books become “important” faster than they become good. The niche itself confers value, because it answers a cultural need, not necessarily because the craft is flawless.
Subtext: the marketplace and the discourse machine (publishers, reviewers, prize committees, book clubs) are constantly hungry for “the” novel that represents a moment or a constituency. White, long central to gay American letters, knows how quickly a single work can be anointed as representative simply because the field is underpopulated or newly visible. The burden on the book becomes unfairly symbolic.
His final clause - “even when it’s a far from perfect fit” - carries both skepticism and rue. Cultural ecosystems don’t wait for ideal specimens. They promote the first credible organism that wanders into the clearing, then retroactively treat it like destiny.
Quote Details
| Topic | Book |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Edmund
Add to List
