"I think there's a great difference in consciousness in that same way in that when we're young we read books for the story, for the excitement of the story - and there comes a time when you realise that all stories are more or less the same story"
About this Quote
McGahern sneaks a whole aesthetic manifesto into the familiar scene of growing up with books. The first move is disarmingly ordinary: youth reads for plot, the sugar-rush of what happens next. Then he pivots to a quieter, more unsettling adult discovery: the world’s narrative inventory is finite. Love, loss, ambition, betrayal, return, escape - shuffle the names and the settings and you can make a thousand novels, but the engine underneath stays stubbornly recognizable.
The line’s power is in its refusal to sound like a boast of sophistication. McGahern isn’t mocking the young reader; he’s naming a shift in consciousness, a change in what we go to art for. Once “all stories are more or less the same story,” the value of fiction has to migrate. It can’t be suspense alone. It becomes voice, sentence texture, moral attention, the particular angle of looking. In other words, what distinguishes literature from content.
That squares with McGahern’s own work and context: an Irish writer shaped by rural life, Catholic discipline, and the aftershocks of censorship and emigration. In a culture where certain plots (family authority, sexual shame, the leaving and longing to return) recur with near-liturgical regularity, repetition isn’t a failure; it’s the point. The adult reader’s revelation isn’t that stories are pointless, but that their sameness is a test. If the plot is preordained, can the writer still make you feel the pressure of a single lived moment? McGahern’s answer is yes - by making the “same story” newly seen.
The line’s power is in its refusal to sound like a boast of sophistication. McGahern isn’t mocking the young reader; he’s naming a shift in consciousness, a change in what we go to art for. Once “all stories are more or less the same story,” the value of fiction has to migrate. It can’t be suspense alone. It becomes voice, sentence texture, moral attention, the particular angle of looking. In other words, what distinguishes literature from content.
That squares with McGahern’s own work and context: an Irish writer shaped by rural life, Catholic discipline, and the aftershocks of censorship and emigration. In a culture where certain plots (family authority, sexual shame, the leaving and longing to return) recur with near-liturgical regularity, repetition isn’t a failure; it’s the point. The adult reader’s revelation isn’t that stories are pointless, but that their sameness is a test. If the plot is preordained, can the writer still make you feel the pressure of a single lived moment? McGahern’s answer is yes - by making the “same story” newly seen.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by John
Add to List
