"I think we typically, as Northerners, stereotype what the South is in so many negative ways. We kind of forget all the beautiful things that they contribute to make this country a country"
About this Quote
That opening “I think” does a lot of quiet work: it softens what could be a sharp rebuke into something more conversational, the kind of tone a TV-facing designer can deliver without sounding like a scold. Genevieve Gorder isn’t trying to litigate Southern history; she’s trying to nudge a mainstream audience out of a lazy cultural reflex - the Northern habit of treating “the South” as a shorthand for backwardness, bigotry, or kitsch.
The key move is the switch from “stereotype” to “forget.” Stereotyping sounds like a moral failing; forgetting sounds like a mistake you can correct. That reframing invites listeners to see themselves as basically decent people who’ve simply let a partial narrative harden. It’s persuasion via salvage: you’re not bad, you’re incomplete.
Her phrase “beautiful things” is intentionally broad, almost design-speak. It leaves room for food, music, architecture, hospitality, vernacular style - the lived textures of a region that gets flattened into political caricature. Coming from a designer, that vagueness is strategic: design is the language of appreciation without requiring ideological agreement. She’s arguing for attention, not absolution.
The subtext, though, is a tension Americans rarely resolve cleanly: how to celebrate regional contributions without laundering regional harms. By emphasizing what “they contribute to make this country a country,” Gorder leans on a unity narrative - an appeal to national wholeness. It’s a plea to widen the frame: not “ignore the South’s failures,” but “stop pretending its story is only failure.”
The key move is the switch from “stereotype” to “forget.” Stereotyping sounds like a moral failing; forgetting sounds like a mistake you can correct. That reframing invites listeners to see themselves as basically decent people who’ve simply let a partial narrative harden. It’s persuasion via salvage: you’re not bad, you’re incomplete.
Her phrase “beautiful things” is intentionally broad, almost design-speak. It leaves room for food, music, architecture, hospitality, vernacular style - the lived textures of a region that gets flattened into political caricature. Coming from a designer, that vagueness is strategic: design is the language of appreciation without requiring ideological agreement. She’s arguing for attention, not absolution.
The subtext, though, is a tension Americans rarely resolve cleanly: how to celebrate regional contributions without laundering regional harms. By emphasizing what “they contribute to make this country a country,” Gorder leans on a unity narrative - an appeal to national wholeness. It’s a plea to widen the frame: not “ignore the South’s failures,” but “stop pretending its story is only failure.”
Quote Details
| Topic | Respect |
|---|
More Quotes by Genevieve
Add to List
