"I thought that the AIVD was there to protect citizens like me"
About this Quote
There is a special kind of sting in the word “thought.” It doesn’t accuse the AIVD (the Dutch intelligence service) of malice so much as of betrayal: the injury is not just what happened, but the collapse of a civic bargain Van Gogh assumed was in place. By framing himself as “citizens like me,” he smuggles in two claims at once: that protection is a right of ordinary democratic membership, and that his particular profile (provocateur, public critic of Islam, loudmouthed artist) should not disqualify him from that right. The line is less plea than indictment dressed as naivete.
In context, it lands like black irony. Van Gogh was living in a Netherlands that prized blunt speech yet was grappling with the real costs of that openness after 9/11, the rise of domestic radicalization, and the political shockwaves following Pim Fortuyn’s assassination. Van Gogh’s own work and persona practically dared institutions to choose: defend pluralism in the messy, offensive, free-speech sense, or retreat into managed calm.
The subtext is also a challenge to the security state’s usual alibi. Intelligence agencies trade on secrecy, competence, and the promise that silence equals safety. Van Gogh punctures that aura with one disappointed sentence: if the state can’t protect even the most visible, threatened critic, what exactly are citizens paying for? It’s a director’s line, too: short, quotable, calibrated for replay, turning bureaucratic failure into a moral plot twist.
In context, it lands like black irony. Van Gogh was living in a Netherlands that prized blunt speech yet was grappling with the real costs of that openness after 9/11, the rise of domestic radicalization, and the political shockwaves following Pim Fortuyn’s assassination. Van Gogh’s own work and persona practically dared institutions to choose: defend pluralism in the messy, offensive, free-speech sense, or retreat into managed calm.
The subtext is also a challenge to the security state’s usual alibi. Intelligence agencies trade on secrecy, competence, and the promise that silence equals safety. Van Gogh punctures that aura with one disappointed sentence: if the state can’t protect even the most visible, threatened critic, what exactly are citizens paying for? It’s a director’s line, too: short, quotable, calibrated for replay, turning bureaucratic failure into a moral plot twist.
Quote Details
| Topic | Human Rights |
|---|
More Quotes by Theo
Add to List


