"I thought what the military was doing was unconstitutional"
About this Quote
There is something deliberately plain, almost stubbornly small, about Korematsu's wording: "I thought". Not "I knew", not "I proved", not "I was right". It reads like understatement, but it's really a moral stance in civilian clothes. In the middle of a national panic, when the government wrapped mass removal and incarceration of Japanese Americans in the language of necessity, Korematsu frames his resistance as a basic act of judgment available to an ordinary person. The sentence refuses the grandiosity of patriotism-as-performance. It insists that constitutional thinking is not the exclusive property of courts, generals, or politicians.
The subtext is sharper than the syntax. "What the military was doing" avoids the euphemisms of the era, but it also points directly at a problem American power likes to hide: when the military becomes the face of domestic policy, legality starts to blur into command. Korematsu is naming that blur and calling it what it is, without ornament. "Unconstitutional" lands like a cold fact, not a slogan. He's not asking to be seen as heroic; he's saying the country broke its own rules.
The context, of course, is the wartime apparatus that treated ancestry as suspicion and due process as optional. Korematsu lost at the Supreme Court in 1944, a decision that still stains the Court's legacy. Decades later, when his conviction was vacated, the quote reads less like hindsight than like a reminder: constitutional crises often arrive wearing the bland uniform of "just following orders", and the first defense is the unimpressive courage to think otherwise.
The subtext is sharper than the syntax. "What the military was doing" avoids the euphemisms of the era, but it also points directly at a problem American power likes to hide: when the military becomes the face of domestic policy, legality starts to blur into command. Korematsu is naming that blur and calling it what it is, without ornament. "Unconstitutional" lands like a cold fact, not a slogan. He's not asking to be seen as heroic; he's saying the country broke its own rules.
The context, of course, is the wartime apparatus that treated ancestry as suspicion and due process as optional. Korematsu lost at the Supreme Court in 1944, a decision that still stains the Court's legacy. Decades later, when his conviction was vacated, the quote reads less like hindsight than like a reminder: constitutional crises often arrive wearing the bland uniform of "just following orders", and the first defense is the unimpressive courage to think otherwise.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Fred
Add to List





