"I tried. But not everybody thought so"
About this Quote
Four clipped words, then a quiet swivel of blame: "I tried. But not everybody thought so". It reads like a confession that refuses to self-flagellate. Andrew Young, a clergyman who lived at the seam between pulpit and public power, uses the plainest possible diction to stage a moral drama Americans know well: effort versus judgment, conscience versus crowd.
"I tried" is the language of testimony. It doesn’t claim victory, holiness, or even competence; it claims intention. For a minister shaped by the civil-rights movement’s discipline of nonviolence and public scrutiny, that matters. Intent is where accountability begins. Then the sentence breaks. The period is a pause you can hear: a breath after endurance, a beat that signals he’s not going to litigate the record.
"But not everybody thought so" shifts the axis from inward to outward. It’s a reminder that in politics and in moral leadership, good faith is never the only currency; perception is. The subtext is sharper than the tone: you can work, sacrifice, negotiate, and still be read as naive, compromised, too radical, not radical enough. Young’s generation learned that the audience for righteousness is fragmented, and the loudest evaluators are often the least charitable.
The line’s power is its pastoral restraint. No counterattack, no martyr pose. Just a weary, practiced acknowledgment that public life turns motives into mirrors: people don’t just assess what you did, they decide what kind of person you are allowed to be.
"I tried" is the language of testimony. It doesn’t claim victory, holiness, or even competence; it claims intention. For a minister shaped by the civil-rights movement’s discipline of nonviolence and public scrutiny, that matters. Intent is where accountability begins. Then the sentence breaks. The period is a pause you can hear: a breath after endurance, a beat that signals he’s not going to litigate the record.
"But not everybody thought so" shifts the axis from inward to outward. It’s a reminder that in politics and in moral leadership, good faith is never the only currency; perception is. The subtext is sharper than the tone: you can work, sacrifice, negotiate, and still be read as naive, compromised, too radical, not radical enough. Young’s generation learned that the audience for righteousness is fragmented, and the loudest evaluators are often the least charitable.
The line’s power is its pastoral restraint. No counterattack, no martyr pose. Just a weary, practiced acknowledgment that public life turns motives into mirrors: people don’t just assess what you did, they decide what kind of person you are allowed to be.
Quote Details
| Topic | Failure |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Andrew
Add to List
