"I try to help people become the best possible editors of their own work, to help them become conscious of the things they do well, of the things they need to look at again, of the wells of material they have not even begun to dip their buckets into"
About this Quote
Wolff frames editing as a transfer of agency, not a service transaction. The verb choice matters: he doesnt "fix" manuscripts, he helps people become "the best possible editors of their own work". That phrasing quietly demotes the mentor from savior to catalyst. It also hints at a pedagogy shaped by the workshop era in American letters, where the real product isnt the polished story on the table but the writer who can walk away and keep revising without a roomful of witnesses.
The sentence is built as a triple inventory: what they do well, what needs another look, what they havent even touched. Its a humane diagnostic, but also a sly rebuke to the common fantasy that talent is a single flame you either have or dont. Wolff assumes abundance. The "wells of material" metaphor is doing heavy lifting here: it suggests depth, renewability, and ownership. The writer already has the source; the problem is access and habit, not a lack of ideas. "Dip their buckets" adds a working-class physicality to the romantic myth of inspiration. Writing becomes labor, repetitive and unglamorous, the kind you get better at by learning where to reach and how to haul.
Subtextually, this is also an ethics statement. A good editor, for Wolff, doesnt colonize a voice. The goal is consciousness: to name strengths without flattering, to identify weaknesses without shaming, to point toward untapped terrain without prescribing what must be found there. In a culture that loves quick fixes and external validation, Wolffs intent is slower and more radical: teach writers to hear themselves, then trust them to do the hard part alone.
The sentence is built as a triple inventory: what they do well, what needs another look, what they havent even touched. Its a humane diagnostic, but also a sly rebuke to the common fantasy that talent is a single flame you either have or dont. Wolff assumes abundance. The "wells of material" metaphor is doing heavy lifting here: it suggests depth, renewability, and ownership. The writer already has the source; the problem is access and habit, not a lack of ideas. "Dip their buckets" adds a working-class physicality to the romantic myth of inspiration. Writing becomes labor, repetitive and unglamorous, the kind you get better at by learning where to reach and how to haul.
Subtextually, this is also an ethics statement. A good editor, for Wolff, doesnt colonize a voice. The goal is consciousness: to name strengths without flattering, to identify weaknesses without shaming, to point toward untapped terrain without prescribing what must be found there. In a culture that loves quick fixes and external validation, Wolffs intent is slower and more radical: teach writers to hear themselves, then trust them to do the hard part alone.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by Tobias
Add to List
