"I try to make my books reflect humanity as I see it"
About this Quote
Hillerman’s line reads like a modest craft note, but it’s also a quiet manifesto about power: who gets to count as “humanity,” and who gets rendered as background scenery. “As I see it” is the tell. He isn’t claiming a god’s-eye view or a sociological survey; he’s owning perspective, admitting that fiction is always a selection, a framing, a bias. That small clause functions as both humility and permission slip: the novels won’t be neutral, they’ll be legible through one writer’s moral and sensory lens.
The intent is practical. Hillerman built his career on the Navajo Nation mysteries, and the books succeed because they treat setting as more than atmosphere. Ritual, language, landscape, and community obligations aren’t exotic garnish; they’re the logic engine of plot and character. “Reflect humanity” signals his refusal to make Indigenous life a metaphor for someone else’s self-discovery. It’s a promise that the people in his pages will have the full range of motives and contradictions that genre fiction often flattens into types.
The subtext, though, is a negotiation with the cultural moment. A non-Navajo author writing deeply inside Navajo worlds is always adjacent to questions of appropriation and authority. “As I see it” anticipates that critique: he can’t claim to speak for a whole people, only to write responsibly from long observation, research, and respect. In the late 20th-century boom of “regional” crime fiction, Hillerman’s edge was insisting that locality is not quaint detail; it’s a different way of being human, and therefore a different way of telling truth.
The intent is practical. Hillerman built his career on the Navajo Nation mysteries, and the books succeed because they treat setting as more than atmosphere. Ritual, language, landscape, and community obligations aren’t exotic garnish; they’re the logic engine of plot and character. “Reflect humanity” signals his refusal to make Indigenous life a metaphor for someone else’s self-discovery. It’s a promise that the people in his pages will have the full range of motives and contradictions that genre fiction often flattens into types.
The subtext, though, is a negotiation with the cultural moment. A non-Navajo author writing deeply inside Navajo worlds is always adjacent to questions of appropriation and authority. “As I see it” anticipates that critique: he can’t claim to speak for a whole people, only to write responsibly from long observation, research, and respect. In the late 20th-century boom of “regional” crime fiction, Hillerman’s edge was insisting that locality is not quaint detail; it’s a different way of being human, and therefore a different way of telling truth.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by Tony
Add to List
