"I try to open up my heart as much as I can and keep a real keen eye out that I don't get sentimental. I think we're all afraid to reveal our hearts. It's not at all in fashion"
About this Quote
Paul Simon frames vulnerability like a tightrope act: open your heart, but don’t lean so hard into feeling that it curdles into sentimentality. That’s not just craft talk; it’s a survival strategy for a songwriter whose whole job is to translate emotion without sounding like he’s begging for approval. The “keen eye” is the editor inside the artist, policing the line where honesty turns into greeting-card bathos. He’s admitting the impulse to bare everything while also confessing his suspicion of emotional spectacle.
The subtext lands on a cultural nerve: we’re trained to treat sincerity as risky and “sentimental” as embarrassing, the way a room full of cool people flinches at anything too earnest. Simon isn’t saying hearts are private; he’s saying we’ve made privacy into a style. “Not at all in fashion” reads like a throwaway, but it’s a quiet indictment of a culture that rewards irony, detachment, and emotional minimalism. If you reveal too much, you become uncool, naive, easy to mock.
Coming from Simon, it also doubles as an aesthetic manifesto. His best songs often move with a surgeon’s precision: intimate details, restrained delivery, ache smuggled in through observation. He wants the door to the heart open, not ripped off its hinges. The line captures the paradox that makes his work endure: feelings are the point, but taste is the filter. In an era where people oscillate between oversharing and armor, Simon argues for a third mode: candor with standards.
The subtext lands on a cultural nerve: we’re trained to treat sincerity as risky and “sentimental” as embarrassing, the way a room full of cool people flinches at anything too earnest. Simon isn’t saying hearts are private; he’s saying we’ve made privacy into a style. “Not at all in fashion” reads like a throwaway, but it’s a quiet indictment of a culture that rewards irony, detachment, and emotional minimalism. If you reveal too much, you become uncool, naive, easy to mock.
Coming from Simon, it also doubles as an aesthetic manifesto. His best songs often move with a surgeon’s precision: intimate details, restrained delivery, ache smuggled in through observation. He wants the door to the heart open, not ripped off its hinges. The line captures the paradox that makes his work endure: feelings are the point, but taste is the filter. In an era where people oscillate between oversharing and armor, Simon argues for a third mode: candor with standards.
Quote Details
| Topic | Love |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Paul
Add to List








