"I visualize a time when we will be to robots what dogs are to humans, and I'm rooting for the machines"
About this Quote
A mathematician’s joke with teeth: Shannon isn’t just forecasting smarter machines, he’s deliberately flipping the usual comfort story in which humans stay the unquestioned masters of their tools. The line works because it’s both a thought experiment and a mild act of heresy. By choosing dogs as the comparison, he avoids the melodrama of “slaves” or “extinction” and lands on something more unsettlingly plausible: an affectionate, dependent relationship where the lesser party is cared for, trained, indulged, and rarely consulted about the big decisions.
The subtext is classic Shannon: intelligence framed as information processing, not soul or status. If minds are, in some meaningful sense, computable, then the trajectory isn’t “robots become like us,” it’s “we become legible to them,” reduced to patterns, preferences, and constraints. Rooting for the machines isn’t a death wish; it’s a provocation aimed at human ego. He’s puncturing the species-level assumption that cognition naturally entitles us to the top rung forever.
Context matters. Shannon helped found information theory right as computing was shifting from wartime machinery to a general-purpose model of thought. Mid-century cybernetics and early AI were already asking whether brains could be treated as circuits. Shannon’s quip sits in that era’s mix of optimism and dread, but with a distinctive move: he makes the punchline ethical. If superior intelligence is coming, what kind of “pet” would we be - loyal companion, spoiled dependent, nuisance? The joke quietly demands we rethink the politics of creating successors, not just the engineering.
The subtext is classic Shannon: intelligence framed as information processing, not soul or status. If minds are, in some meaningful sense, computable, then the trajectory isn’t “robots become like us,” it’s “we become legible to them,” reduced to patterns, preferences, and constraints. Rooting for the machines isn’t a death wish; it’s a provocation aimed at human ego. He’s puncturing the species-level assumption that cognition naturally entitles us to the top rung forever.
Context matters. Shannon helped found information theory right as computing was shifting from wartime machinery to a general-purpose model of thought. Mid-century cybernetics and early AI were already asking whether brains could be treated as circuits. Shannon’s quip sits in that era’s mix of optimism and dread, but with a distinctive move: he makes the punchline ethical. If superior intelligence is coming, what kind of “pet” would we be - loyal companion, spoiled dependent, nuisance? The joke quietly demands we rethink the politics of creating successors, not just the engineering.
Quote Details
| Topic | Artificial Intelligence |
|---|
More Quotes by Claude
Add to List





