"I will not take "but" for an answer"
About this Quote
A single syllable turns into a barricade. “But” is the sound of permission withheld, of a door opened just wide enough to remind you who controls the hinges. Langston Hughes’s line refuses that choreography. It isn’t merely stubbornness; it’s a rhetorical strike against the polite, ever-ready qualifying clause that softens injustice into something tolerable. “I will not take ‘but’ for an answer” treats hesitation as a tactic, not a temperament.
Hughes built a career on exposing how America’s promises arrive with conditions attached: freedom, but; equality, but; belonging, but. In the Harlem Renaissance and its aftermath, Black aspiration was constantly met with “not now,” “be reasonable,” “wait your turn,” often delivered in the language of civility. The genius here is how the quote captures that whole structure in a tiny grammatical object. He doesn’t argue with the full refusal; he targets the hedge, the part that pretends to be fair-minded while keeping the outcome unchanged.
There’s also a poet’s ear at work: “but” is abrupt, percussive, a hard stop. Hughes turns that stop into a provocation. The sentence flips the power dynamic by declaring what counts as an acceptable response. The speaker isn’t asking for hope or sympathy; he’s demanding unqualified commitment. In a culture trained to praise “nuance” when it really means delay, Hughes makes impatience feel like moral clarity.
Hughes built a career on exposing how America’s promises arrive with conditions attached: freedom, but; equality, but; belonging, but. In the Harlem Renaissance and its aftermath, Black aspiration was constantly met with “not now,” “be reasonable,” “wait your turn,” often delivered in the language of civility. The genius here is how the quote captures that whole structure in a tiny grammatical object. He doesn’t argue with the full refusal; he targets the hedge, the part that pretends to be fair-minded while keeping the outcome unchanged.
There’s also a poet’s ear at work: “but” is abrupt, percussive, a hard stop. Hughes turns that stop into a provocation. The sentence flips the power dynamic by declaring what counts as an acceptable response. The speaker isn’t asking for hope or sympathy; he’s demanding unqualified commitment. In a culture trained to praise “nuance” when it really means delay, Hughes makes impatience feel like moral clarity.
Quote Details
| Topic | Never Give Up |
|---|
More Quotes by Langston
Add to List
