"Ideals are like the stars: we never reach them, but like the mariners of the sea, we chart our course by them"
About this Quote
Schurz reaches for the oldest navigational technology in the book and turns it into an argument for disciplined idealism. Stars are fixed, cold, and indifferent to human effort; mariners are practical people who can drown. Pairing the two is the point: ideals aren’t trophies to be won, they’re instruments that keep you from drifting. The line flatters aspiration while refusing the sentimental payoff of “achieving your dreams.” You never arrive at a star; you still steer by it.
The subtext is a rebuke to two temptations that dog politics, especially in eras of upheaval: cynicism (“ideals are useless because they’re unattainable”) and fanaticism (“the ideal must be made real at any cost”). Schurz offers a third posture: accept the distance, keep the direction. It’s a quiet pitch for moral measurement over moral triumph, a way to justify incremental progress without sounding like surrender.
Context sharpens the edge. Schurz was a 1848 German revolutionary who fled repression, then reinvented himself in American public life, arguing against slavery and later against corruption and imperial overreach. Revolutions teach you how quickly purity becomes brutality, and how quickly pragmatism becomes excuse. The nautical metaphor smuggles in that hard-earned realism: the sea is messy, the weather changes, and you still need something stable to orient yourself.
Rhetorically, it works because it makes unattainability a feature, not a flaw. The stars don’t move to meet you; you move with intention because they won’t.
The subtext is a rebuke to two temptations that dog politics, especially in eras of upheaval: cynicism (“ideals are useless because they’re unattainable”) and fanaticism (“the ideal must be made real at any cost”). Schurz offers a third posture: accept the distance, keep the direction. It’s a quiet pitch for moral measurement over moral triumph, a way to justify incremental progress without sounding like surrender.
Context sharpens the edge. Schurz was a 1848 German revolutionary who fled repression, then reinvented himself in American public life, arguing against slavery and later against corruption and imperial overreach. Revolutions teach you how quickly purity becomes brutality, and how quickly pragmatism becomes excuse. The nautical metaphor smuggles in that hard-earned realism: the sea is messy, the weather changes, and you still need something stable to orient yourself.
Rhetorically, it works because it makes unattainability a feature, not a flaw. The stars don’t move to meet you; you move with intention because they won’t.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Carl
Add to List



