"Idolatry is in a man's own thought, not in the opinion of another"
About this Quote
Selden’s line is a quiet grenade lobbed into a 17th-century world obsessed with policing other people’s worship. Written by a jurist-statesman who lived through England’s sectarian crack-ups, it shifts the crime scene of idolatry from the public square to the private mind. That’s not just theological hair-splitting; it’s political self-defense. If idolatry is primarily an interior act - a mis-ordering of devotion, a turning of the intellect into a shrine - then the zealot’s favorite target (your neighbor’s “wrong” ritual) becomes secondary, even beside the point.
The intent is surgical: Selden is cutting the fuse between accusation and authority. Early modern regimes used “idolatry” as a multipurpose charge to discipline dissent, justify censorship, and legitimize violence. By insisting it lives “in a man’s own thought,” he strips institutions of their easiest pretext: you can condemn behavior, but you can’t reliably govern consciousness without becoming monstrous or ridiculous. The subtext carries a dry warning to moral crusaders: your certainty about others’ spiritual errors may itself be the idol - an infatuation with your own judgment.
It also reads as a proto-liberal intuition about responsibility. Selden doesn’t absolve belief; he relocates accountability. The line implies that real corruption isn’t the statue, the ceremony, the aesthetic surface. It’s the mental habit of granting ultimate authority to something that can’t bear it - including, pointedly, the crowd’s opinion. In an age of conformity-by-surveillance, Selden argues that the most dangerous idol is the one you build inside your own head.
The intent is surgical: Selden is cutting the fuse between accusation and authority. Early modern regimes used “idolatry” as a multipurpose charge to discipline dissent, justify censorship, and legitimize violence. By insisting it lives “in a man’s own thought,” he strips institutions of their easiest pretext: you can condemn behavior, but you can’t reliably govern consciousness without becoming monstrous or ridiculous. The subtext carries a dry warning to moral crusaders: your certainty about others’ spiritual errors may itself be the idol - an infatuation with your own judgment.
It also reads as a proto-liberal intuition about responsibility. Selden doesn’t absolve belief; he relocates accountability. The line implies that real corruption isn’t the statue, the ceremony, the aesthetic surface. It’s the mental habit of granting ultimate authority to something that can’t bear it - including, pointedly, the crowd’s opinion. In an age of conformity-by-surveillance, Selden argues that the most dangerous idol is the one you build inside your own head.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by John
Add to List











