"If a man be gloomy let him keep to himself. No one has the right to go croaking about society, or what is worse, looking as if he stifled grief"
About this Quote
Disraeli’s line lands with the cold efficiency of a man who understood politics as atmosphere management. “If a man be gloomy let him keep to himself” isn’t just a personal preference; it’s a governing principle for public life: emotions are contagious, and a leader’s job is to control the room. The verb “croaking” is doing the dirty work. It reduces public despair to an animal noise - not tragedy, not insight, not even critique, just an ugly sound that spoils conversation. Disraeli isn’t arguing against grief so much as against grief performed in public as a kind of moral claim.
The sharper barb comes next: “or what is worse, looking as if he stifled grief.” That “worse” is revealing. Loud melancholy is irritating; theatrical restraint is dangerous. The person who seems to choke back sorrow projects accusation without stating it, solicits sympathy while denying it, and makes everyone else feel implicated. Disraeli’s contempt is for emotional blackmail - the social sabotage of implied suffering.
As a Victorian statesman, Disraeli spoke from a culture that prized self-command and treated public feeling as a civic resource. He also operated in the brutal theatre of Parliament, where mood could be weaponized and “gloom” could stand in for pessimism about the nation, the economy, the empire. The intent, then, is disciplinary: keep your private darkness private, because public melancholy isn’t authenticity; it’s a bid for power without accountability.
The sharper barb comes next: “or what is worse, looking as if he stifled grief.” That “worse” is revealing. Loud melancholy is irritating; theatrical restraint is dangerous. The person who seems to choke back sorrow projects accusation without stating it, solicits sympathy while denying it, and makes everyone else feel implicated. Disraeli’s contempt is for emotional blackmail - the social sabotage of implied suffering.
As a Victorian statesman, Disraeli spoke from a culture that prized self-command and treated public feeling as a civic resource. He also operated in the brutal theatre of Parliament, where mood could be weaponized and “gloom” could stand in for pessimism about the nation, the economy, the empire. The intent, then, is disciplinary: keep your private darkness private, because public melancholy isn’t authenticity; it’s a bid for power without accountability.
Quote Details
| Topic | Sadness |
|---|
More Quotes by Benjamin
Add to List
