"If a person studies too much and exhausts his reflective powers, he will be confused, and will not be able to apprehend even that which had been within the power of his apprehension. For the powers of the body are all alike in this respect"
About this Quote
The sting in Maimonides' warning is that it’s aimed less at the lazy than at the devout striver. Medieval intellectual life, especially in the Jewish philosophical tradition he helped define, could treat study as a moral sport: more hours, more texts, more refinement. He punctures that piety with an almost clinical observation: the mind is not a bottomless vessel, and scholarship can become self-sabotage.
The intent is practical, even preventative. Maimonides is policing the boundary between disciplined inquiry and cognitive overreach. “Exhausts his reflective powers” frames thinking as a finite faculty with recovery costs, like muscles. That analogy is the subtextual pivot: he smuggles a proto-psychological realism into a culture that often sacralized relentless learning. If your body can be overworked into weakness, your intellect can be overstudied into confusion.
Context matters because Maimonides isn’t an anti-intellectual. He’s the philosopher-physician who tried to harmonize revelation with reason, Aristotelian method with religious law. So this isn’t an argument for ignorance; it’s an argument for sustainable clarity. He’s implicitly critiquing a certain kind of anxious scholarship: the reader who mistakes accumulation for understanding and treats mental strain as evidence of virtue.
The rhetorical move is quietly subversive. By insisting that excessive study can make you lose even what you already “had been within the power” to grasp, he reframes humility as cognitive hygiene. Limits aren’t capitulation; they’re guardrails. In an age of both information overload and performative productivity, that medieval caution reads less like quaint moderation and more like a diagnosis.
The intent is practical, even preventative. Maimonides is policing the boundary between disciplined inquiry and cognitive overreach. “Exhausts his reflective powers” frames thinking as a finite faculty with recovery costs, like muscles. That analogy is the subtextual pivot: he smuggles a proto-psychological realism into a culture that often sacralized relentless learning. If your body can be overworked into weakness, your intellect can be overstudied into confusion.
Context matters because Maimonides isn’t an anti-intellectual. He’s the philosopher-physician who tried to harmonize revelation with reason, Aristotelian method with religious law. So this isn’t an argument for ignorance; it’s an argument for sustainable clarity. He’s implicitly critiquing a certain kind of anxious scholarship: the reader who mistakes accumulation for understanding and treats mental strain as evidence of virtue.
The rhetorical move is quietly subversive. By insisting that excessive study can make you lose even what you already “had been within the power” to grasp, he reframes humility as cognitive hygiene. Limits aren’t capitulation; they’re guardrails. In an age of both information overload and performative productivity, that medieval caution reads less like quaint moderation and more like a diagnosis.
Quote Details
| Topic | Study Motivation |
|---|
More Quotes by Maimonides
Add to List









