"If a policy is wrongheaded, feckless and corrupt, I take it personally and consider it a moral obligation to sound off and not shut up until it's fixed"
About this Quote
Hackworth turns bureaucratic failure into personal insult, and that’s the point: he’s yanking policy out of the safe, abstract realm of “strategy” and dragging it into the mud where soldiers live and die. The triple hit of “wrongheaded, feckless and corrupt” isn’t just colorful disgust; it’s a diagnostic. Wrongheaded means intellectually incompetent. Feckless means cowardly or lax in execution. Corrupt means morally rotten. He’s saying the harm isn’t accidental or merely political - it’s layered, predictable, and therefore blameworthy.
The engine of the line is the clash between institution and conscience. A soldier is supposed to follow orders, not litigate them in public. Hackworth flips that script: loyalty to the mission and to the people doing the fighting requires disloyalty to the paper-pushers when they’re steering into disaster. “I take it personally” reads like ego at first, but the subtext is accountability: if policy sets the conditions of survival, then indifference is complicity. He’s carving out a soldier’s version of whistleblowing that doesn’t ask permission.
“Sound off and not shut up” lands with barracks bluntness, a deliberately unpolished rebuke to euphemism and committee language. It also signals a Vietnam-era sensibility, when the gap between official narratives and on-the-ground reality became intolerable. Hackworth is claiming a moral rank higher than formal rank: when governance is broken, silence isn’t discipline - it’s surrender.
The engine of the line is the clash between institution and conscience. A soldier is supposed to follow orders, not litigate them in public. Hackworth flips that script: loyalty to the mission and to the people doing the fighting requires disloyalty to the paper-pushers when they’re steering into disaster. “I take it personally” reads like ego at first, but the subtext is accountability: if policy sets the conditions of survival, then indifference is complicity. He’s carving out a soldier’s version of whistleblowing that doesn’t ask permission.
“Sound off and not shut up” lands with barracks bluntness, a deliberately unpolished rebuke to euphemism and committee language. It also signals a Vietnam-era sensibility, when the gap between official narratives and on-the-ground reality became intolerable. Hackworth is claiming a moral rank higher than formal rank: when governance is broken, silence isn’t discipline - it’s surrender.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|
More Quotes by David
Add to List
