"If a reporter doesn't like the person he's writing about, it shows up in his article"
About this Quote
Stargell’s line lands like clubhouse wisdom, but it’s really an indictment of the myth of neutral narration. He’s pointing to the telltale leakage that happens when a writer’s private feelings seep into supposedly objective prose: the loaded adjective, the selective quote, the suspiciously “minor” mistake that never gets corrected. It’s not just about fairness; it’s about power. Reporters don’t merely describe athletes, they help manufacture public reputations, and Stargell is naming the hidden thumb on the scale.
The intent is practical: a warning to journalists and a heads-up to subjects. Athletes learn quickly that the story isn’t only the box score; it’s the tone around the box score. A reporter who dislikes you can turn hustle into “showboating,” intensity into “attitude,” confidence into “arrogance.” None of it has to be a lie to function as a smear. The subtext is that relationships matter, and not in a sentimental way. Access journalism, beat culture, and the daily grind of being in each other’s orbit make sports writing uniquely vulnerable to petty grudges and favoritism.
Context matters, too. Stargell played through an era when players had less control over their image, long before social media gave athletes direct channels to fans. Back then, the beat writer’s framing could stick for years. His quote anticipates today’s media literacy: the audience can sense bias, but it helps when the person being covered says the quiet part out loud.
The intent is practical: a warning to journalists and a heads-up to subjects. Athletes learn quickly that the story isn’t only the box score; it’s the tone around the box score. A reporter who dislikes you can turn hustle into “showboating,” intensity into “attitude,” confidence into “arrogance.” None of it has to be a lie to function as a smear. The subtext is that relationships matter, and not in a sentimental way. Access journalism, beat culture, and the daily grind of being in each other’s orbit make sports writing uniquely vulnerable to petty grudges and favoritism.
Context matters, too. Stargell played through an era when players had less control over their image, long before social media gave athletes direct channels to fans. Back then, the beat writer’s framing could stick for years. His quote anticipates today’s media literacy: the audience can sense bias, but it helps when the person being covered says the quiet part out loud.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by Willie
Add to List
