"If absolute power corrupts absolutely, does absolute powerlessness make you pure?"
About this Quote
Shearer’s question lands like a heckler’s pebble tossed at a sacred statue: it takes Lord Acton’s famous maxim about power and corruption and flips it into an uncomfortable mirror for everyone who thinks virtue is just what happens when you’re denied the chance to do harm. The phrasing is slyly legalistic - “If... does...” - the tone of a cross-examination that already knows the witness is lying. It’s a joke built as a trap.
The intent isn’t to rehabilitate “powerlessness” as noble; it’s to puncture the romance of it. In American culture, especially in entertainment and political commentary (Shearer’s home turf), victimhood can become a moral credential, a way of winning arguments without taking responsibility. Shearer is needling the idea that being shut out of institutions automatically makes you ethically superior. The subtext: plenty of people are powerless not because they’re pure, but because they’re disorganized, compromised, apathetic, or simply unlucky - and many would wield power brutally if handed it tomorrow.
It also doubles as a warning to the powerful: don’t dismiss the powerless as harmless. Powerlessness doesn’t cleanse desire; it concentrates it. The line’s real sting is that it removes everyone’s alibi. If corruption isn’t only a product of access, then virtue isn’t only a product of constraint. Purity, Shearer implies, is a practice, not a position.
The intent isn’t to rehabilitate “powerlessness” as noble; it’s to puncture the romance of it. In American culture, especially in entertainment and political commentary (Shearer’s home turf), victimhood can become a moral credential, a way of winning arguments without taking responsibility. Shearer is needling the idea that being shut out of institutions automatically makes you ethically superior. The subtext: plenty of people are powerless not because they’re pure, but because they’re disorganized, compromised, apathetic, or simply unlucky - and many would wield power brutally if handed it tomorrow.
It also doubles as a warning to the powerful: don’t dismiss the powerless as harmless. Powerlessness doesn’t cleanse desire; it concentrates it. The line’s real sting is that it removes everyone’s alibi. If corruption isn’t only a product of access, then virtue isn’t only a product of constraint. Purity, Shearer implies, is a practice, not a position.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Harry
Add to List
