"If all printers were determined not to print anything till they were sure it would offend nobody, there would be very little printed"
About this Quote
Franklin’s genius here is that he smuggles a radical defense of dissent into a homespun observation about the printing business. He doesn’t romanticize “free speech” as an abstract virtue; he treats it as a practical inevitability. Printing, by definition, creates friction. The moment ideas leave the private mind and enter public circulation, they collide with pride, doctrine, class interest, and authority. If you require universal comfort as the admission ticket to publication, you don’t get a gentler public sphere - you get silence, or propaganda.
The line is also a shrewd rebuke to self-censorship disguised as decency. Franklin spots the moral pose: the printer who claims he’s only avoiding offense is often avoiding risk. “Offend nobody” sounds like civility; Franklin reveals it as cowardice with good manners. His tone is lightly comic, but the subtext is hard-edged: a public that demands not to be disturbed will end up uneducated, and leaders who fear controversy will find it easier to manage that public.
Context matters: Franklin lived in an era when printers were political actors, not neutral service providers. Pamphlets, broadsides, and newspapers were the bloodstream of revolutionary argument, and authorities knew it. His point is less about protecting speech everyone likes than preserving the messy ecosystem that makes democratic conflict possible. The punchline - “very little printed” - is an empirical warning: a culture that mistakes “inoffensive” for “responsible” chooses stagnation, and calls it virtue.
The line is also a shrewd rebuke to self-censorship disguised as decency. Franklin spots the moral pose: the printer who claims he’s only avoiding offense is often avoiding risk. “Offend nobody” sounds like civility; Franklin reveals it as cowardice with good manners. His tone is lightly comic, but the subtext is hard-edged: a public that demands not to be disturbed will end up uneducated, and leaders who fear controversy will find it easier to manage that public.
Context matters: Franklin lived in an era when printers were political actors, not neutral service providers. Pamphlets, broadsides, and newspapers were the bloodstream of revolutionary argument, and authorities knew it. His point is less about protecting speech everyone likes than preserving the messy ecosystem that makes democratic conflict possible. The punchline - “very little printed” - is an empirical warning: a culture that mistakes “inoffensive” for “responsible” chooses stagnation, and calls it virtue.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Benjamin
Add to List


