"If anything's progressive, then we make progress"
About this Quote
The line lands like a backstage pep talk dressed up as a manifesto: progress isn’t a badge you earn by naming yourself “progressive,” it’s something you prove by moving the work forward. Giles, coming out of a world where “progressive” became both a genre tag and a marketing claim, is quietly puncturing the vanity of the label. He’s saying: stop fetishizing the adjective and show me the verb.
The phrasing matters. “If anything’s progressive” is slippery on purpose, a little shrug of skepticism toward the endless debates about what counts as real innovation. He doesn’t define progressive; he sets a test. The conditional “if” turns ideology into a hypothesis, and “then we make progress” makes the payoff brutally practical. It’s an artist’s logic: the only metric that survives the noise is whether the next thing actually changes what came before.
There’s also a band-dynamic subtext here. “We” isn’t the royal we of a visionary genius; it’s collaborative, the plural voice of musicianship. Progress becomes collective labor: rehearsal rooms, risk-taking, edits, arguments, the unglamorous commitment to not repeating yourself. In an era when “progressive” can harden into a style box (long songs, technical chops, conceptual albums), Giles reframes it as a discipline of momentum. The intent reads less like philosophy and more like a warning to artists who confuse complexity with advancement: if the music isn’t pushing somewhere, the label is just costume.
The phrasing matters. “If anything’s progressive” is slippery on purpose, a little shrug of skepticism toward the endless debates about what counts as real innovation. He doesn’t define progressive; he sets a test. The conditional “if” turns ideology into a hypothesis, and “then we make progress” makes the payoff brutally practical. It’s an artist’s logic: the only metric that survives the noise is whether the next thing actually changes what came before.
There’s also a band-dynamic subtext here. “We” isn’t the royal we of a visionary genius; it’s collaborative, the plural voice of musicianship. Progress becomes collective labor: rehearsal rooms, risk-taking, edits, arguments, the unglamorous commitment to not repeating yourself. In an era when “progressive” can harden into a style box (long songs, technical chops, conceptual albums), Giles reframes it as a discipline of momentum. The intent reads less like philosophy and more like a warning to artists who confuse complexity with advancement: if the music isn’t pushing somewhere, the label is just costume.
Quote Details
| Topic | Motivational |
|---|
More Quotes by Michael
Add to List
