"If Carter had been there when the AIDS crisis came up, it would have been a whole different story. It could have been treated like a legitimate disease"
About this Quote
O'Leary’s line lands like an accusation delivered in the calm tone of a counterfactual. By invoking Jimmy Carter, she isn’t nostalgia-shopping for a nicer president; she’s naming the deadly cost of indifference as policy. The phrase "If Carter had been there" compresses a decade of loss into a single hinge moment, suggesting that leadership is not symbolic in a crisis - it is biomedical. Funding, public messaging, and institutional urgency decide who lives long enough for treatments to arrive.
The sting is in her modest phrasing: "a whole different story" and "could have been treated". That understatement is strategic. It implies that what happened was so grotesquely avoidable it barely needs dramatizing. Most damning is "legitimate disease". O'Leary points to the way AIDS was framed less as an epidemic than as a moral referendum on gay men, sex workers, and drug users. Legitimacy here isn’t medical; it’s social. A disease becomes "real" only when the people it kills are considered worth saving.
Context sharpens the intent. The early AIDS years unfolded under Reagan-era conservatism, when silence from the top communicated permission to stigmatize and delay. Activists like O'Leary fought not only for research dollars and healthcare access, but for the right to be mourned publicly without shame. By contrasting Carter’s reputation for humane governance with the administration that followed, she sketches a brutal thesis: the crisis wasn’t just viral. It was political - and that politics decided which deaths counted.
The sting is in her modest phrasing: "a whole different story" and "could have been treated". That understatement is strategic. It implies that what happened was so grotesquely avoidable it barely needs dramatizing. Most damning is "legitimate disease". O'Leary points to the way AIDS was framed less as an epidemic than as a moral referendum on gay men, sex workers, and drug users. Legitimacy here isn’t medical; it’s social. A disease becomes "real" only when the people it kills are considered worth saving.
Context sharpens the intent. The early AIDS years unfolded under Reagan-era conservatism, when silence from the top communicated permission to stigmatize and delay. Activists like O'Leary fought not only for research dollars and healthcare access, but for the right to be mourned publicly without shame. By contrasting Carter’s reputation for humane governance with the administration that followed, she sketches a brutal thesis: the crisis wasn’t just viral. It was political - and that politics decided which deaths counted.
Quote Details
| Topic | Health |
|---|
More Quotes by Jean
Add to List
