"If forced to choose between the penitentiary and the White House for four years, I would say the penitentiary, thank you"
About this Quote
Sherman’s punch line lands because it inverts the era’s biggest status symbol. The White House is supposed to be the apex of ambition; he treats it like a sentence. By pairing it with the penitentiary, he doesn’t just insult politics, he reframes it as captivity: four years of confinement, surveillance, and compulsory performance. The “thank you” is the blade twist - a note of manners that makes the contempt feel colder, more controlled, and therefore more believable.
The specific intent was practical as much as theatrical. After the Civil War, Sherman was a national celebrity and an obvious target for the “try him for president” impulse that keeps recurring in American life. His refusal isn’t coy modesty; it’s a preemptive strike against being drafted into a role he saw as corrosive, compromising, and structurally impossible to do honestly. A soldier can at least claim clear lines: command, mission, outcome. A president answers to factions, patronage networks, newspapers, and a public hungry for symbolic gestures more than hard choices. Sherman had watched how war forced brutal clarity; peace-time governance often rewarded ambiguity.
The subtext is also self-protective. He’s warning that the job doesn’t just test character; it reshapes it. Better a cell with known limits than a mansion that quietly demands your surrender to constant bargaining. Coming from a general associated with “hard war,” the remark doubles as a cultural critique: Americans romanticize leadership, then punish leaders for acting like adults. Sherman’s quip is less anti-democratic than anti-fantasy - a refusal to let hero worship turn into hostage-taking.
The specific intent was practical as much as theatrical. After the Civil War, Sherman was a national celebrity and an obvious target for the “try him for president” impulse that keeps recurring in American life. His refusal isn’t coy modesty; it’s a preemptive strike against being drafted into a role he saw as corrosive, compromising, and structurally impossible to do honestly. A soldier can at least claim clear lines: command, mission, outcome. A president answers to factions, patronage networks, newspapers, and a public hungry for symbolic gestures more than hard choices. Sherman had watched how war forced brutal clarity; peace-time governance often rewarded ambiguity.
The subtext is also self-protective. He’s warning that the job doesn’t just test character; it reshapes it. Better a cell with known limits than a mansion that quietly demands your surrender to constant bargaining. Coming from a general associated with “hard war,” the remark doubles as a cultural critique: Americans romanticize leadership, then punish leaders for acting like adults. Sherman’s quip is less anti-democratic than anti-fantasy - a refusal to let hero worship turn into hostage-taking.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by William
Add to List




