"If I commit an error I do it without bad intention"
About this Quote
A soldier’s most self-exculpating line is often a claim about the heart, not the hands. “If I commit an error I do it without bad intention” is a preemptive moral alibi: it separates culpability from consequence, asking to be judged by motive rather than outcome. The conditional “if” does quiet work here. It doesn’t admit wrongdoing; it anticipates accusations and tries to manage how history files them.
Stand Watie’s context makes that maneuver loaded. A Cherokee leader who became a Confederate brigadier general, Watie fought in a civil war nested inside another: U.S. vs. Confederacy, and internal Cherokee factional conflict shaped by removal, treaty disputes, and retaliation. In that landscape, “error” is never just a mistake on a battlefield. It can mean choosing a side, authorizing raids, seizing supplies, aligning with a government that defended slavery, or acting against political rivals within his own nation. Calling any of that an “error” shrinks moral scope to human fallibility.
The subtext is a plea for a narrower lens. Watie is staking out a familiar wartime defense: decisions made under pressure, with incomplete information, in the name of survival. “Without bad intention” tries to salvage honor in a world where honor is currency and indictment. It’s also a hint of how leaders want to be remembered when the winds shift: not as villains, not as opportunists, but as men caught in history’s vice, trying to keep agency without owning the harm.
The line works because it is both humble and evasive, a soft sentence designed to carry hard consequences.
Stand Watie’s context makes that maneuver loaded. A Cherokee leader who became a Confederate brigadier general, Watie fought in a civil war nested inside another: U.S. vs. Confederacy, and internal Cherokee factional conflict shaped by removal, treaty disputes, and retaliation. In that landscape, “error” is never just a mistake on a battlefield. It can mean choosing a side, authorizing raids, seizing supplies, aligning with a government that defended slavery, or acting against political rivals within his own nation. Calling any of that an “error” shrinks moral scope to human fallibility.
The subtext is a plea for a narrower lens. Watie is staking out a familiar wartime defense: decisions made under pressure, with incomplete information, in the name of survival. “Without bad intention” tries to salvage honor in a world where honor is currency and indictment. It’s also a hint of how leaders want to be remembered when the winds shift: not as villains, not as opportunists, but as men caught in history’s vice, trying to keep agency without owning the harm.
The line works because it is both humble and evasive, a soft sentence designed to carry hard consequences.
Quote Details
| Topic | Honesty & Integrity |
|---|
More Quotes by Stand
Add to List






