"If I create from the heart, nearly everything works; if from the head, almost nothing"
About this Quote
Chagall is pitching a heresy against the tidy myth of the “rational” modern artist: that the best work is engineered, solved, optimized. He frames creation as a binary not because he believed painters should be dumb, but because he understood how easily craft can become a cage. “From the head” isn’t intelligence; it’s obedience to systems - to fashion, to theory, to the anxious inner accountant tallying what will look serious, sell, or be legible to gatekeepers. The line reads like a private corrective, the kind you repeat to yourself when you feel your hand stiffen.
It also slyly defends what critics sometimes dismissed in Chagall: the floating lovers, the animals, the dream logic, the bright folkloric symbols that refuse to behave like proper avant-garde argumentation. The heart, here, is not sentimentality; it’s access to memory, mysticism, and the half-conscious material that makes his canvases feel like waking inside a fable. He’s insisting that feeling is a method.
Context matters. Chagall lived through pogroms, exile, revolution, two world wars - periods when “the head” often meant ideology, manifestos, and the deadening certainty of political programs. Against that, he chose an art of interior truth: not escapism, but survival. The punch of “nearly everything” versus “almost nothing” is deliberately lopsided, a provocation aimed at fellow artists tempted to paint like they’re writing a brief. He’s saying: technique can get you competence; only the heart gets you necessity.
It also slyly defends what critics sometimes dismissed in Chagall: the floating lovers, the animals, the dream logic, the bright folkloric symbols that refuse to behave like proper avant-garde argumentation. The heart, here, is not sentimentality; it’s access to memory, mysticism, and the half-conscious material that makes his canvases feel like waking inside a fable. He’s insisting that feeling is a method.
Context matters. Chagall lived through pogroms, exile, revolution, two world wars - periods when “the head” often meant ideology, manifestos, and the deadening certainty of political programs. Against that, he chose an art of interior truth: not escapism, but survival. The punch of “nearly everything” versus “almost nothing” is deliberately lopsided, a provocation aimed at fellow artists tempted to paint like they’re writing a brief. He’s saying: technique can get you competence; only the heart gets you necessity.
Quote Details
| Topic | Art |
|---|---|
| Source | Marc Chagall — Wikiquote entry (quote: "If I create from the heart, nearly everything works; if from the head, almost nothing"). |
More Quotes by Marc
Add to List








