"If I have my way, I'm going to dissolve the Forest Service. They're in the business of harvesting trees and they're not harvesting trees, so why have them anymore?"
About this Quote
It’s the kind of line that tries to make government sound like a busted vending machine: you put in tax dollars, you’re supposed to get a product, and if the product doesn’t drop, you kick the whole thing over. Don Young frames the Forest Service as a single-purpose outfit - “in the business of harvesting trees” - then convicts it of failing its own mission. The move is rhetorically efficient: redefine a complex agency as a one-line job description, then argue it deserves liquidation for underperformance.
The subtext is older and more ideological. Young isn’t merely mad about paperwork or inefficiency; he’s advancing a worldview where public land is justified primarily by extraction. Conservation, wildfire mitigation, habitat protection, recreation, tribal consultation, and watershed stewardship all get erased so the audience can hear a clean, economically legible promise: more cutting, fewer constraints. By turning “not harvesting trees” into a moral failure, he aligns environmental regulation with idleness and casts preservation as a betrayal of working people and local economies.
The context matters: Young, an Alaska congressman, spent decades championing resource development and fighting federal oversight in the West and North. His quote lands in the long-running timber wars and the post-1990s reality where litigation, endangered species protections, and public opposition reduced logging on federal lands. “Dissolve the Forest Service” isn’t a serious administrative plan so much as a pressure tactic - a threat designed to delegitimize the referee so the game can be played on industry terms.
The subtext is older and more ideological. Young isn’t merely mad about paperwork or inefficiency; he’s advancing a worldview where public land is justified primarily by extraction. Conservation, wildfire mitigation, habitat protection, recreation, tribal consultation, and watershed stewardship all get erased so the audience can hear a clean, economically legible promise: more cutting, fewer constraints. By turning “not harvesting trees” into a moral failure, he aligns environmental regulation with idleness and casts preservation as a betrayal of working people and local economies.
The context matters: Young, an Alaska congressman, spent decades championing resource development and fighting federal oversight in the West and North. His quote lands in the long-running timber wars and the post-1990s reality where litigation, endangered species protections, and public opposition reduced logging on federal lands. “Dissolve the Forest Service” isn’t a serious administrative plan so much as a pressure tactic - a threat designed to delegitimize the referee so the game can be played on industry terms.
Quote Details
| Topic | Nature |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Don
Add to List







