"If I may take the liberty to speak for science at least, today his name and his prizes are without a peer in the world. He not only elevates science but he influences it as well"
About this Quote
A scientist praising a prize is never just flattery; its a bid to define what counts as legitimate science. Melvin Calvin, speaking from inside the Nobel ecosystem, frames "his name and his prizes" as "without a peer", then slips in the more consequential claim: this figure "not only elevates science but he influences it as well". Elevation is the safe compliment: visibility, prestige, a brighter spotlight on research. Influence is the sharper, slightly uneasy admission that awards dont merely reflect scientific greatness; they steer it.
Calvin is careful with his opening hedge, "If I may take the liberty to speak for science at least". That modesty is strategic. He positions himself as a spokesperson for an entire enterprise, while signaling that what follows is bigger than personal opinion. The phrase "for science" also narrows the territory: whatever political, cultural, or economic baggage might cling to prize culture, here it is framed as an internal scientific matter - a kind of professional consensus.
The subtext is a recognition of science as a social system with incentives. Prizes concentrate attention, funding, and careers; they create a map of what problems are worth solving and what styles of work are admirable. Calvin, a Nobel laureate himself, understands that authority circulates through these symbols. Calling the prize-maker unrivaled is also a defense of the hierarchy that elevated him - and a reminder that the person who hands out prestige doesnt just reward science after the fact; he helps write its agenda.
Calvin is careful with his opening hedge, "If I may take the liberty to speak for science at least". That modesty is strategic. He positions himself as a spokesperson for an entire enterprise, while signaling that what follows is bigger than personal opinion. The phrase "for science" also narrows the territory: whatever political, cultural, or economic baggage might cling to prize culture, here it is framed as an internal scientific matter - a kind of professional consensus.
The subtext is a recognition of science as a social system with incentives. Prizes concentrate attention, funding, and careers; they create a map of what problems are worth solving and what styles of work are admirable. Calvin, a Nobel laureate himself, understands that authority circulates through these symbols. Calling the prize-maker unrivaled is also a defense of the hierarchy that elevated him - and a reminder that the person who hands out prestige doesnt just reward science after the fact; he helps write its agenda.
Quote Details
| Topic | Science |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Melvin
Add to List







