"If it has to choose who is to be crucified, the crowd will always save Barabbas"
About this Quote
Cocteau’s line is a cold little machine: it takes a sacred story and runs it as a diagnostic test for modern mass taste. The Barabbas episode in the Gospels is already a parable about failed moral perception, but Cocteau sharpens it into a rule. Not sometimes, not in ancient Jerusalem, not under unusual pressure: always. That absolutism is the point. It’s less theology than audience theory.
A director knows what crowds reward: the legible villain, the loud gesture, the familiar type. Barabbas is “content” before content exists - a recognizable bad boy, a plot you can follow with your gut. Jesus, in Cocteau’s framing, is harder: his power is inward, his revolution isn’t easily consumable, his innocence is destabilizing because it makes the crowd complicit. Saving Barabbas is a way of saving yourself from the demand of transformation. You can cheer for the rogue and still feel worldly; you can condemn the innocent and still feel unanimous.
The subtext is a warning about democracy’s aesthetics as much as its ethics. Collective choice doesn’t automatically elevate the best; it often selects the most satisfying narrative. Cocteau’s era knew how quickly publics could be orchestrated, how spectacle could launder cruelty into entertainment. Read as a director’s aside, the line is also self-implicating: if you stage the world as a spectacle, don’t be surprised when the audience votes for the performance that flatters their instincts.
A director knows what crowds reward: the legible villain, the loud gesture, the familiar type. Barabbas is “content” before content exists - a recognizable bad boy, a plot you can follow with your gut. Jesus, in Cocteau’s framing, is harder: his power is inward, his revolution isn’t easily consumable, his innocence is destabilizing because it makes the crowd complicit. Saving Barabbas is a way of saving yourself from the demand of transformation. You can cheer for the rogue and still feel worldly; you can condemn the innocent and still feel unanimous.
The subtext is a warning about democracy’s aesthetics as much as its ethics. Collective choice doesn’t automatically elevate the best; it often selects the most satisfying narrative. Cocteau’s era knew how quickly publics could be orchestrated, how spectacle could launder cruelty into entertainment. Read as a director’s aside, the line is also self-implicating: if you stage the world as a spectacle, don’t be surprised when the audience votes for the performance that flatters their instincts.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Jean
Add to List










