"If it's a good LP, you'll get that tingle that makes you put it on again no matter what your initial reaction was. On the other hand, if you don't get that tingle, you'd better take it straight down to the record exchange"
About this Quote
Partridge reduces music criticism to a bodily reflex: the tingle. Not “craft,” not “importance,” not the slow-burn Stockholm syndrome of hype - a quick, involuntary shiver that overrides your first take. It’s an unglamorous standard, almost anti-intellectual, and that’s the point. In a culture where people defend albums like positions in a debate, he argues for an ethic of listening that’s private, physical, and stubbornly repeatable.
The sly move is how he treats “initial reaction” as basically noise. First listens are contaminated by expectations, peer consensus, and the pressure to have the “right” opinion on schedule. The tingle is a delayed fuse: if the record keeps calling you back, it’s doing what art is supposed to do - generating desire rather than merely delivering information. It’s also a rebuke to the idea that good taste is a performance. Your body can’t posture as easily as your Twitter feed.
Then he turns consumer pragmatist: if the tingle doesn’t arrive, trade it in. There’s humor in the bluntness, but also a quiet empowerment. You’re not morally obligated to do homework for an album that isn’t meeting you halfway. Coming from a musician who lived through the LP era’s gatekeepers - record stores, critics, scarce access - it reads as both a defense of the listener’s time and a reminder that records aren’t sacred objects. They’re tools for feeling; if they don’t spark, let them circulate to someone they will.
The sly move is how he treats “initial reaction” as basically noise. First listens are contaminated by expectations, peer consensus, and the pressure to have the “right” opinion on schedule. The tingle is a delayed fuse: if the record keeps calling you back, it’s doing what art is supposed to do - generating desire rather than merely delivering information. It’s also a rebuke to the idea that good taste is a performance. Your body can’t posture as easily as your Twitter feed.
Then he turns consumer pragmatist: if the tingle doesn’t arrive, trade it in. There’s humor in the bluntness, but also a quiet empowerment. You’re not morally obligated to do homework for an album that isn’t meeting you halfway. Coming from a musician who lived through the LP era’s gatekeepers - record stores, critics, scarce access - it reads as both a defense of the listener’s time and a reminder that records aren’t sacred objects. They’re tools for feeling; if they don’t spark, let them circulate to someone they will.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Andy
Add to List


