"If love is the answer, could you please rephrase the question?"
About this Quote
Tomlin’s line lands like a rimshot after a long, sanctimonious sermon: it punctures the cozy assumption that “love” is a usable solution to anything harder than a Hallmark card. The genius is in the grammar. “If love is the answer” borrows the cadence of self-help platitudes and civic-religious rhetoric, the kind that treats emotion as policy. Then she swerves into bureaucratic politeness - “could you please” - as if she’s filing a customer-service complaint against the entire culture of easy uplift. That courtesy isn’t softness; it’s a scalpel. By staying calm, she makes the original cliché look hysterical.
The subtext is impatience with vague moralizing: love as an answer to war, inequality, loneliness, sexism - all the messy systems that don’t yield to good vibes. Tomlin doesn’t deny love’s value; she refuses its misuse as a conversation-stopper. “Rephrase the question” is the real demand. Get specific. Name the problem. Stop treating “love” as a magic word that absolves us from thinking, organizing, or changing anything.
Context matters because Tomlin’s comedy has always been a Trojan horse for social critique, delivered with a smile that lets the knife in. Coming out of an era saturated with New Age optimism and political sloganeering, the joke reads as both countercultural and practical: affection without analysis is sentimentality; empathy without structure is just another way to avoid responsibility. The punchline doesn’t cancel love - it asks for a better language, and a more honest plan.
The subtext is impatience with vague moralizing: love as an answer to war, inequality, loneliness, sexism - all the messy systems that don’t yield to good vibes. Tomlin doesn’t deny love’s value; she refuses its misuse as a conversation-stopper. “Rephrase the question” is the real demand. Get specific. Name the problem. Stop treating “love” as a magic word that absolves us from thinking, organizing, or changing anything.
Context matters because Tomlin’s comedy has always been a Trojan horse for social critique, delivered with a smile that lets the knife in. Coming out of an era saturated with New Age optimism and political sloganeering, the joke reads as both countercultural and practical: affection without analysis is sentimentality; empathy without structure is just another way to avoid responsibility. The punchline doesn’t cancel love - it asks for a better language, and a more honest plan.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|---|
| Source | Quote attributed to Lily Tomlin , listed on Wikiquote (Lily Tomlin page); original primary source not specified there. |
More Quotes by Lily
Add to List










