"If modesty and candor are necessary to an author in his judgment of his own works, no less are they in his reader"
About this Quote
Modesty and candor aren’t virtues here; they’re tools for reading without turning literature into a mirror. Sarah Fielding’s line quietly rearranges the power dynamic between author and audience. We tend to think the writer bears the ethical burden: don’t oversell, don’t flatter yourself, don’t mistake draftwork for genius. Fielding agrees, then swivels the obligation onto the reader, where it stings. If an author must be humble and honest about what they’ve made, the reader must be equally humble and honest about what they’re bringing to it.
The intent is corrective, aimed at the kind of judgment that masquerades as sophistication: snap dismissal, moral grandstanding, the pleasure of catching a flaw more than understanding a design. “Modesty” asks the reader to admit their limits - of taste, knowledge, patience - and to resist the fantasy that their reaction is the final verdict. “Candor” is the counterweight: don’t hide behind vague dislike or fashionable contempt; say plainly what fails, what persuades, what you may have missed.
Context matters. Fielding wrote in an 18th-century literary culture thick with reviews, salons, and reputational warfare, and as a woman author she was operating under extra scrutiny and patronizing “proper” standards. The subtext is tactical: reading is a moral practice, not because books make you good, but because judgment reveals character. She’s asking for an ethic of criticism that’s neither submissive nor cruel - just brave enough to be fair.
The intent is corrective, aimed at the kind of judgment that masquerades as sophistication: snap dismissal, moral grandstanding, the pleasure of catching a flaw more than understanding a design. “Modesty” asks the reader to admit their limits - of taste, knowledge, patience - and to resist the fantasy that their reaction is the final verdict. “Candor” is the counterweight: don’t hide behind vague dislike or fashionable contempt; say plainly what fails, what persuades, what you may have missed.
Context matters. Fielding wrote in an 18th-century literary culture thick with reviews, salons, and reputational warfare, and as a woman author she was operating under extra scrutiny and patronizing “proper” standards. The subtext is tactical: reading is a moral practice, not because books make you good, but because judgment reveals character. She’s asking for an ethic of criticism that’s neither submissive nor cruel - just brave enough to be fair.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Sarah
Add to List
