"If my duty does involve heralding His law in every arena, then the Church in America is failing radically today"
About this Quote
The line lands like a courtroom objection disguised as a confession: if I really am obligated to trumpet God’s law everywhere, then America’s churches are blowing it. Randall Terry isn’t offering a private devotional worry; he’s setting up a public indictment that turns personal “duty” into an institutional verdict. The “if” pretends humility, but it’s a rhetorical trap. Accept the premise - that faith requires political and cultural dominance - and the conclusion is already loaded: the Church is not merely off-track, it’s “failing radically,” a phrase that frames moderation as moral collapse.
“Heralding” matters. It’s not “living” or “witnessing,” verbs that suggest persuasion or example. It’s proclamation, authority, broadcast. “His law” similarly bypasses messy democratic argument and denominational nuance; it implies a clear, singular code that should govern “every arena,” a totalizing claim that erases the boundary between pulpit and policy. The subtext is a rebuke to churches focused on charity, pastoral care, or pluralistic civic engagement: if they aren’t engaged in culture-war enforcement, they’re derelict.
Contextually, Terry comes out of the late-20th-century American Religious Right, where activism around abortion and “family values” recast the church as a political engine. Calling the Church a radical failure also functions as a recruitment tool. It manufactures crisis, elevates the speaker as the one willing to say what others won’t, and pressures believers to choose sides: either join the crusade across “every arena,” or accept the stigma of cowardice dressed up as faith.
“Heralding” matters. It’s not “living” or “witnessing,” verbs that suggest persuasion or example. It’s proclamation, authority, broadcast. “His law” similarly bypasses messy democratic argument and denominational nuance; it implies a clear, singular code that should govern “every arena,” a totalizing claim that erases the boundary between pulpit and policy. The subtext is a rebuke to churches focused on charity, pastoral care, or pluralistic civic engagement: if they aren’t engaged in culture-war enforcement, they’re derelict.
Contextually, Terry comes out of the late-20th-century American Religious Right, where activism around abortion and “family values” recast the church as a political engine. Calling the Church a radical failure also functions as a recruitment tool. It manufactures crisis, elevates the speaker as the one willing to say what others won’t, and pressures believers to choose sides: either join the crusade across “every arena,” or accept the stigma of cowardice dressed up as faith.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Randall
Add to List


