"If one is seriously interested in preventing reproductive cloning, one must stop the process before it starts"
About this Quote
The line weaponizes pragmatism to smuggle in a moral verdict. Kass isn’t arguing about how to regulate cloning; he’s arguing that regulation is a trap. “Seriously interested” draws a line between responsible adults and naïve technophiles, implying that anyone open to incremental oversight isn’t truly committed to prevention. Then comes the real move: “stop the process before it starts” reframes a messy scientific and political debate as a matter of timing and willpower. If cloning is the feared outcome, the only “serious” posture is preemption.
That’s not just policy advice. It’s a strategy for closing democratic argument by relocating the decisive moment upstream, into labs, funding streams, and permissive research norms. Kass’s subtext is that once the machinery of biomedical innovation begins to turn, social constraints won’t hold: curiosity, competition, and institutional momentum will carry society past its stated limits. The sentence assumes a slippery slope, but it does so in the calm, administrative voice of inevitability rather than panic.
The context matters. Kass rose to prominence as a bioethics gatekeeper in the late-1990s/early-2000s, when Dolly the sheep made cloning feel suddenly plausible and the Bush-era President’s Council on Bioethics debated how far to let reproductive and therapeutic cloning research go. His diction echoes public-health prevention language, borrowing the authority of “early intervention” to justify bans at the level of research itself. It’s a compact argument for moral quarantine: treat cloning not as a technology to domesticate, but as a contagion to intercept before it gains a foothold.
That’s not just policy advice. It’s a strategy for closing democratic argument by relocating the decisive moment upstream, into labs, funding streams, and permissive research norms. Kass’s subtext is that once the machinery of biomedical innovation begins to turn, social constraints won’t hold: curiosity, competition, and institutional momentum will carry society past its stated limits. The sentence assumes a slippery slope, but it does so in the calm, administrative voice of inevitability rather than panic.
The context matters. Kass rose to prominence as a bioethics gatekeeper in the late-1990s/early-2000s, when Dolly the sheep made cloning feel suddenly plausible and the Bush-era President’s Council on Bioethics debated how far to let reproductive and therapeutic cloning research go. His diction echoes public-health prevention language, borrowing the authority of “early intervention” to justify bans at the level of research itself. It’s a compact argument for moral quarantine: treat cloning not as a technology to domesticate, but as a contagion to intercept before it gains a foothold.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Leon
Add to List
