"If people around the world knew how well people at Guantanamo Bay are treating prisoners, they would not fall prey to the accusations that some in our Chamber are making. They are all receiving judicial review"
About this Quote
A politician’s defense rarely hinges on proving innocence; it hinges on narrowing the argument to what can be managed on the record. Robin Hayes’s line does that with practiced economy: it shifts the debate from Guantanamo’s legitimacy to Guantanamo’s optics. “If people around the world knew” is a preemptive strike on perception, implying the problem isn’t policy but ignorance - and by extension, that critics are either misinformed or malicious. It’s a soft form of propaganda, inviting audiences to distrust the accusation before they’ve even heard the evidence.
The phrase “treating prisoners” is the rhetorical centerpiece. It swaps the vocabulary of rights for the vocabulary of care. “Treating” suggests benevolence, even hospitality, while “prisoners” quietly normalizes a contested category at Guantanamo: detainees held in a legal gray zone, often without the timelines or charges the public associates with ordinary incarceration. Hayes tries to shut that door with a reassuring technicality: “They are all receiving judicial review.” Not “trial,” not “due process,” not “habeas corpus” - “review,” a word that sounds procedural, tidy, and, crucially, minimal.
The subtext is political triage. In the post-9/11 era, Guantanamo became less a facility than a symbol: of American power, fear-driven policy, and international blowback. Hayes’s intent is to reframe that symbol as an administrative misunderstanding and to paint dissent “in our Chamber” as opportunistic. It’s not an argument meant to persuade skeptics; it’s a script designed to reassure allies and close ranks.
The phrase “treating prisoners” is the rhetorical centerpiece. It swaps the vocabulary of rights for the vocabulary of care. “Treating” suggests benevolence, even hospitality, while “prisoners” quietly normalizes a contested category at Guantanamo: detainees held in a legal gray zone, often without the timelines or charges the public associates with ordinary incarceration. Hayes tries to shut that door with a reassuring technicality: “They are all receiving judicial review.” Not “trial,” not “due process,” not “habeas corpus” - “review,” a word that sounds procedural, tidy, and, crucially, minimal.
The subtext is political triage. In the post-9/11 era, Guantanamo became less a facility than a symbol: of American power, fear-driven policy, and international blowback. Hayes’s intent is to reframe that symbol as an administrative misunderstanding and to paint dissent “in our Chamber” as opportunistic. It’s not an argument meant to persuade skeptics; it’s a script designed to reassure allies and close ranks.
Quote Details
| Topic | Human Rights |
|---|
More Quotes by Robin
Add to List
