"If there is an authoritarian structure at St. Hill it has been brought into being by the government itself. St. Hill is trying to correct itself. It doesn't know what it's trying to correct because nobody has told it what to correct"
About this Quote
Hubbard’s genius here is bureaucratic jujitsu: he concedes the accusation (authoritarian structure) only to relocate the blame to a faceless, meddling state. It’s a move designed to feel candid while doing what propaganda always does best - shifting causality. “If there is” softens the admission into a hypothetical, but the next clause snaps into certainty: the government “brought [it] into being.” The organization becomes not an aggressor but a victim, forced into hard edges by external pressure.
The second beat - “St. Hill is trying to correct itself” - is the sound of a system laundering its own authority. “Correct” implies a moral calibration rather than a power struggle: discipline becomes self-improvement, compliance becomes healing. That framing is crucial because it recasts internal control as therapeutic necessity, not domination.
Then he lands the real payload: “It doesn’t know what it’s trying to correct because nobody has told it what to correct.” The line weaponizes uncertainty. If there are problems, they’re undefined; if there are standards, they’re withheld. Government becomes simultaneously omnipotent (it creates authoritarianism) and incompetent (it won’t specify violations). It’s an argument built to make oversight impossible: regulators are accused of causing the very harm they’re investigating, then faulted for not offering a roadmap to fix it.
Contextually, St. Hill Manor was Scientology’s UK headquarters during years of mounting scrutiny. Hubbard is speaking to protect institutional legitimacy, but he’s also speaking inward: reassuring followers that any tightening of the screws is reluctant, reactive, and ultimately righteous. The subtext is clear: trust us, distrust them, and interpret control as defense.
The second beat - “St. Hill is trying to correct itself” - is the sound of a system laundering its own authority. “Correct” implies a moral calibration rather than a power struggle: discipline becomes self-improvement, compliance becomes healing. That framing is crucial because it recasts internal control as therapeutic necessity, not domination.
Then he lands the real payload: “It doesn’t know what it’s trying to correct because nobody has told it what to correct.” The line weaponizes uncertainty. If there are problems, they’re undefined; if there are standards, they’re withheld. Government becomes simultaneously omnipotent (it creates authoritarianism) and incompetent (it won’t specify violations). It’s an argument built to make oversight impossible: regulators are accused of causing the very harm they’re investigating, then faulted for not offering a roadmap to fix it.
Contextually, St. Hill Manor was Scientology’s UK headquarters during years of mounting scrutiny. Hubbard is speaking to protect institutional legitimacy, but he’s also speaking inward: reassuring followers that any tightening of the screws is reluctant, reactive, and ultimately righteous. The subtext is clear: trust us, distrust them, and interpret control as defense.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Ron Hubbard
Add to List



