"If they can prove that I am wrong by that time, I will give it up to their wisdom, but not after to any one's judgment, till I see the end of another year; for the Lord will begin with a new century; and I will see what he will do, before I will hearken to any man's judgment"
About this Quote
Southcott’s genius here is how she turns a deadline into a stage prop, then dares you to stop watching. She offers a conditional surrender - “If they can prove that I am wrong by that time” - but rigs the condition so it can never really bite. Proof must arrive on her timetable, under her rules, before an invisible cosmic reset (“a new century”) that conveniently keeps the verdict perpetually pending. It’s a rhetorical escrow account: skepticism can deposit objections, but withdrawal is always delayed.
The subtext is less about theology than authority. “Their wisdom” sounds humble, yet it’s a carefully controlled deference that allows her to appear reasonable while refusing actual accountability. Once the clock passes her chosen point, she elevates her claims above “any man’s judgment,” relocating the dispute from public reason to divine unfolding. That move is classic prophetic insulation: when reality threatens to falsify the prediction, shift the arena from evidence to revelation, from calendar time to sacred time.
Context matters: Southcott wasn’t merely a private mystic; she was a mass phenomenon in late-18th/early-19th-century Britain, a working-class woman who built a following through printed prophecies, “seals,” and apocalyptic expectation. Her language reflects that precarious celebrity - both embattled and self-mythologizing. She anticipates ridicule and builds a bunker out of time itself, turning the turn of the century into a narrative cliffhanger.
What makes the passage work is its audacity: it invites scrutiny, then declares the final judge has not yet entered the room.
The subtext is less about theology than authority. “Their wisdom” sounds humble, yet it’s a carefully controlled deference that allows her to appear reasonable while refusing actual accountability. Once the clock passes her chosen point, she elevates her claims above “any man’s judgment,” relocating the dispute from public reason to divine unfolding. That move is classic prophetic insulation: when reality threatens to falsify the prediction, shift the arena from evidence to revelation, from calendar time to sacred time.
Context matters: Southcott wasn’t merely a private mystic; she was a mass phenomenon in late-18th/early-19th-century Britain, a working-class woman who built a following through printed prophecies, “seals,” and apocalyptic expectation. Her language reflects that precarious celebrity - both embattled and self-mythologizing. She anticipates ridicule and builds a bunker out of time itself, turning the turn of the century into a narrative cliffhanger.
What makes the passage work is its audacity: it invites scrutiny, then declares the final judge has not yet entered the room.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|
More Quotes by Joanna
Add to List






