"If thou art a man, admire those who attempt great things, even though they fail"
About this Quote
Admiration belongs first to the courageous attempt, not to the tidy outcome. Seneca addresses the reader with the Roman language of virtus, the quality of a fully realized human being, urging respect for those who take on what is worthy and difficult even at the risk of defeat. Success, he suggests, is a fickle verdict of Fortune; character is revealed in the choice to strive for something larger than comfort or safety.
Stoic ethics separates what is up to us from what is not. Outcomes, applause, and luck are not ours to command; intention, effort, and rational purpose are. To honor only the victorious is to mistake Fortune for virtue. To honor the bold and principled struggler is to align with a truer standard: the steadfast will that refuses pettiness and inertia. This is not an excuse for rashness. The attempt must be great in both scale and moral aim, guided by reason and oriented toward the common good. Seneca praises magnanimity, not vanity.
The line carries a personal resonance. Living amid imperial intrigue, exile, and finally compelled suicide, Seneca knew that acting justly can end badly in worldly terms. Yet he urges a nobler metric: better a worthy failure than a timid life that never risks integrity. Seen this way, failure does not soil the agent; it tests and clarifies the soul. The shame lies less in falling short than in never attempting what duty and imagination demand.
There is also a civic lesson. A society that admires only winners breeds caution, flattery, and triviality. A society that honors brave attempts nurtures innovation, moral courage, and resilience. Admiration becomes a form of nourishment, sustaining those who undertake burdens on behalf of others. To be fully human, Seneca implies, is to recognize greatness in the striving itself and to reserve our highest respect for the person who, guided by reason and purpose, stakes their life on it, whether Fortune crowns them or not.
Stoic ethics separates what is up to us from what is not. Outcomes, applause, and luck are not ours to command; intention, effort, and rational purpose are. To honor only the victorious is to mistake Fortune for virtue. To honor the bold and principled struggler is to align with a truer standard: the steadfast will that refuses pettiness and inertia. This is not an excuse for rashness. The attempt must be great in both scale and moral aim, guided by reason and oriented toward the common good. Seneca praises magnanimity, not vanity.
The line carries a personal resonance. Living amid imperial intrigue, exile, and finally compelled suicide, Seneca knew that acting justly can end badly in worldly terms. Yet he urges a nobler metric: better a worthy failure than a timid life that never risks integrity. Seen this way, failure does not soil the agent; it tests and clarifies the soul. The shame lies less in falling short than in never attempting what duty and imagination demand.
There is also a civic lesson. A society that admires only winners breeds caution, flattery, and triviality. A society that honors brave attempts nurtures innovation, moral courage, and resilience. Admiration becomes a form of nourishment, sustaining those who undertake burdens on behalf of others. To be fully human, Seneca implies, is to recognize greatness in the striving itself and to reserve our highest respect for the person who, guided by reason and purpose, stakes their life on it, whether Fortune crowns them or not.
Quote Details
| Topic | Motivational |
|---|
More Quotes by Seneca
Add to List
