"If we divine a discrepancy between a man's words and his character, the whole impression of him becomes broken and painful; he revolts the imagination by his lack of unity, and even the good in him is hardly accepted"
About this Quote
Cooley is diagnosing a social wound: the moment someone’s stated values and their lived self fall out of alignment, our perception doesn’t merely adjust, it fractures. The phrasing is clinical, but the emotional payload is almost visceral. “Broken and painful” suggests that hypocrisy isn’t just a moral failure we observe; it’s a kind of cognitive injury we experience. We invest in people as coherent stories. When the plot contradicts itself, the reader feels cheated.
The key move is “he revolts the imagination.” Cooley isn’t claiming the person becomes objectively monstrous; he’s saying the listener’s mind recoils because it can’t comfortably picture the person as a single, continuous character. That word “unity” matters. In Cooley’s sociological world, the self is not a sealed interior essence; it’s assembled in interaction, in the steady performance of cues that others use to stabilize who we are. When words and character diverge, the performance glitches. The audience loses the ability to place you.
The darkest line is that “even the good in him is hardly accepted.” Once trust in coherence collapses, virtues start to look like tactics. Kindness reads as branding, generosity as cover, principle as convenience. Cooley’s subtext is less about individual sin than about the social cost of inconsistency: communities run on interpretability. If people can’t predict you, they can’t coordinate with you, and admiration turns into suspicion. In that sense, integrity isn’t saintliness; it’s legibility.
The key move is “he revolts the imagination.” Cooley isn’t claiming the person becomes objectively monstrous; he’s saying the listener’s mind recoils because it can’t comfortably picture the person as a single, continuous character. That word “unity” matters. In Cooley’s sociological world, the self is not a sealed interior essence; it’s assembled in interaction, in the steady performance of cues that others use to stabilize who we are. When words and character diverge, the performance glitches. The audience loses the ability to place you.
The darkest line is that “even the good in him is hardly accepted.” Once trust in coherence collapses, virtues start to look like tactics. Kindness reads as branding, generosity as cover, principle as convenience. Cooley’s subtext is less about individual sin than about the social cost of inconsistency: communities run on interpretability. If people can’t predict you, they can’t coordinate with you, and admiration turns into suspicion. In that sense, integrity isn’t saintliness; it’s legibility.
Quote Details
| Topic | Honesty & Integrity |
|---|
More Quotes by Charles
Add to List
