"If we fight our enemy using the same inhumane and morally bankrupt techniques that we are trying to stop, we will simply become what we have beheld"
About this Quote
Markey’s line is a warning disguised as a strategy memo: you can win the skirmish and still lose the country. The sentence is built like a conditional trapdoor - “If we fight...” - forcing listeners to confront the premise before they can enjoy the comfort of patriotic certainty. By stacking “inhumane” with “morally bankrupt,” he turns tactics into a balance sheet of national character: cruelty isn’t just wrong, it’s a liability that compounds.
The specific intent is to draw a bright ethical boundary around how power should be used in moments when fear makes shortcuts feel practical. In post-9/11 politics - torture debates, surveillance expansions, indefinite detention, “enhanced” everything - Markey’s argument aims at the bipartisan temptation to treat values as peacetime luxuries. He’s not merely condemning an enemy; he’s diagnosing the way democracies self-harm when they borrow the tools of authoritarianism and call it necessity.
The subtext is darker: the enemy doesn’t have to defeat you to change you. They just have to provoke you into abandoning your own constraints. “Become what we have beheld” carries an almost biblical menace, suggesting that moral contamination is contagious, that staring too long at brutality normalizes it. Markey frames ethical restraint not as softness but as self-preservation: the point of fighting is not only to stop a threat, but to remain the kind of society worth defending when the threat is gone.
The specific intent is to draw a bright ethical boundary around how power should be used in moments when fear makes shortcuts feel practical. In post-9/11 politics - torture debates, surveillance expansions, indefinite detention, “enhanced” everything - Markey’s argument aims at the bipartisan temptation to treat values as peacetime luxuries. He’s not merely condemning an enemy; he’s diagnosing the way democracies self-harm when they borrow the tools of authoritarianism and call it necessity.
The subtext is darker: the enemy doesn’t have to defeat you to change you. They just have to provoke you into abandoning your own constraints. “Become what we have beheld” carries an almost biblical menace, suggesting that moral contamination is contagious, that staring too long at brutality normalizes it. Markey frames ethical restraint not as softness but as self-preservation: the point of fighting is not only to stop a threat, but to remain the kind of society worth defending when the threat is gone.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Ed
Add to List
