"If we were really tough on crime, we'd try to save our children from the desperation and deprivation that leave them primed for a life of crime"
About this Quote
“Tough on crime” is one of American politics’ most durable costumes: it sounds like strength, it photographs well, it dodges messy causes. Carrie P. Meek punctures that branding by redefining toughness as prevention, not punishment. The line is built like a trap. It borrows the swagger of law-and-order rhetoric, then flips it into an indictment: if you’re serious, you don’t wait for the mugshot; you intervene at the point where poverty turns into probability.
Her key move is the causal chain: “desperation and deprivation” don’t excuse crime, they explain its pipeline. “Primed” is the knife word. It suggests preparation by environment, as if society is cocking the trigger and then acting shocked by the bang. That’s not soft-hearted sentimentality; it’s an argument about responsibility and timing. The real test of resolve is whether we’ll invest in children before harm is done, when policy is less theatrical and more expensive: schools, housing stability, mental health care, addiction treatment, jobs that pay.
The subtext is a critique of selective empathy. America often funds cages more readily than childcare, patrol cars more readily than counselors. Meek, a Black woman legislator who came of age under segregation and represented communities living with both over-policing and under-resourcing, is also speaking from proximity to the damage. The quote aims at the moral vanity of punitive politics: punishing the predictable outcome while refusing to touch the conditions that make it predictable.
Her key move is the causal chain: “desperation and deprivation” don’t excuse crime, they explain its pipeline. “Primed” is the knife word. It suggests preparation by environment, as if society is cocking the trigger and then acting shocked by the bang. That’s not soft-hearted sentimentality; it’s an argument about responsibility and timing. The real test of resolve is whether we’ll invest in children before harm is done, when policy is less theatrical and more expensive: schools, housing stability, mental health care, addiction treatment, jobs that pay.
The subtext is a critique of selective empathy. America often funds cages more readily than childcare, patrol cars more readily than counselors. Meek, a Black woman legislator who came of age under segregation and represented communities living with both over-policing and under-resourcing, is also speaking from proximity to the damage. The quote aims at the moral vanity of punitive politics: punishing the predictable outcome while refusing to touch the conditions that make it predictable.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|
More Quotes by Carrie
Add to List






