"If we wish to make a new world we have the material ready. The first one, too, was made out of chaos"
About this Quote
Quillen’s line is optimism with a journalist’s hard stare: stop waiting for perfect conditions. “Material ready” is a blunt inversion of the usual excuse-making that treats social change like a luxury item on backorder. He’s telling readers that the raw stuff of reform isn’t rare; it’s piled around us in plain sight - conflict, displacement, inequality, frustration - the very conditions people cite as proof that transformation is impossible.
The trick is the second sentence, which smuggles a creation myth into a political argument. By invoking “chaos” as the origin point of “the first” world, Quillen reframes disorder from scandal to resource. Chaos isn’t a malfunction; it’s the primordial state. That’s both reassurance and warning. Reassurance, because upheaval doesn’t mean the project has failed. Warning, because the comfort of stability is revealed as contingent, even temporary, and no one gets to pretend the current order is nature itself.
As a working journalist writing in the first half of the 20th century - an era of world war, labor unrest, rapid industrialization, and mass persuasion - Quillen is also poking at the era’s managerial fantasies: the idea that progress arrives only through tidy plans and respectable incrementalism. His subtext is that history doesn’t hand us clean clay; it hands us debris. The moral challenge isn’t to eliminate chaos before acting, but to decide what to build from it - and who gets to be the builder.
The trick is the second sentence, which smuggles a creation myth into a political argument. By invoking “chaos” as the origin point of “the first” world, Quillen reframes disorder from scandal to resource. Chaos isn’t a malfunction; it’s the primordial state. That’s both reassurance and warning. Reassurance, because upheaval doesn’t mean the project has failed. Warning, because the comfort of stability is revealed as contingent, even temporary, and no one gets to pretend the current order is nature itself.
As a working journalist writing in the first half of the 20th century - an era of world war, labor unrest, rapid industrialization, and mass persuasion - Quillen is also poking at the era’s managerial fantasies: the idea that progress arrives only through tidy plans and respectable incrementalism. His subtext is that history doesn’t hand us clean clay; it hands us debris. The moral challenge isn’t to eliminate chaos before acting, but to decide what to build from it - and who gets to be the builder.
Quote Details
| Topic | New Beginnings |
|---|---|
| Source | Quote attributed to Robert Quillen; listed on Wikiquote (Robert Quillen page). Original primary source not cited there. |
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List






